Skip to main content

EVALUANDO LA DEUDA DE RECUPERACION DE SERVICIOS ECOSISTEMICOS PROVISTOS POR LA FAUNA EN CULTIVOS PERMANENTES: EFECTO DE LA INTENSIFICACION AGRICOLA Y EL PAISAJE EN OLIVARES

PID2019-108332GB-I00

•
Funding agency name Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Funding agency acronym AEI
Program Programa Estatal de I+D+i Orientado a los Retos de la Sociedad
Call Proyectos de I+D+i (Generación de Conocimiento y Retos Investigación)
Call year 2019
State Plan 2017-2020 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Beneficiary centre UNIVERSIDAD DE JAEN

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 8
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

RODIN. Repositorio de Objetos de Docencia e Investigación de la Universidad de Cádiz
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Woodland loss differently affects seed dispersal by resident and migratory avian frugivores in olive grove-dominated landscapes

  • Tarifa Murcia, Rubén
  • González Varo, Juan Pedro
  • Camacho, Francisco M.
  • Pérez, Antonio J.
  • Salido, Teresa
  • Rey, Pedro J.
Seed dispersal by frugivores is a key ecological process underpinning the functionality of woodland patches and their capacity to maintain biodiversity in agricultural landscapes. Resident and migratory avian frugivores differ in temporal span of their local occurrence, as well as in mobility and territoriality. However, whether landscape homogenization by agriculture affects seed dispersal by avian frugivores differing in migratory strategy remains largely unexplored. We hypothesized a positive role of woodland patches on avian frugivore abundance and seed-dispersal frequency, and a differential impact of woodland loss and landscape simplification on resident and migratory frugivorous birds. We tested these hypotheses in 20 farms distributed along a gradient of woodland loss and olive cropland expansion in south Spain, considering woodland patches and olive fields as two habitats to survey avian frugivore abundance and frequency of seed dispersal. We confirmed that both the abundance and seed-dispersal frequency of avian frugivores were higher in woodland patches than in olive fields, and also that both decayed with decreasing woodland cover. This was largely mediated by a few European (winter) migrants and secondarily by some resident species. However, the woodland patches were unable to intercept sub-Saharan (summer) migrants in sufficient numbers as to make their contribution to dispersal of summer fruits meaningful. Woodland patches with higher seed-dispersal function were located predominantly in landscapes with high woodland cover and/or fruit availability. Moreover, a relatively high woodland cover in the landscape enhanced the seed dispersal function in woodland patches through a balance between high overall frugivore abundance and dispersal frequency, and some increased activity of resident and summer migrants. Our results also inform that the presence of particularly fruit-rich woodland patches can compensate the woodland cover required to maintain the function by enhancing the frequency of seed dispersal of all migratory groups. In contrast, to maintain the function of fruit-poor woodlands their cover at landscape scale should increase. Preserving and restoring woodland patches at landscape scale and enhancing their abundance and diversity of fruits could boost the activity of different disperser groups and their functional complementarity across agricultural landscapes.
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Partitioning beta diversity to untangle mechanisms underlying the assembly of bird communities in Mediterranean olive groves

  • García-Navas, Vicente
  • Martínez-Núñez, Carlos
  • Tarifa, Rubén
  • Molina-Pardo, José L.
  • Valera, Francisco
  • Salido, Teresa
  • Camacho, Francisco M.
  • Rey, Pedro J.
We investigated taxonomic and functional beta diversity of bird communities inhabiting Mediterranean olive groves subject to either intensive or low-intensity management of the ground cover and located in landscapes with different degrees of complexity. Location: Andalusia, southern Spain. Methods: We partitioned taxonomic and functional beta diversity into its two additive components, turnover and nestedness. We also explored the contributions of single sites to overall beta diversity (LCBD) and separated the effects of species replacement (turnover) and richness difference (nestedness) in order to identify ecologically unique sites—keystone communities—within the metacommunity. In a further step, we employed abundance-and functional-based indicator species analyses to characterize bird assemblages. Results: Taxonomic beta diversity increased with landscape complexity. Although both taxonomic and functional differences among assemblages were driven mainly by species replacement (regardless of management or landscape type), the contribution of trait replacement to the total functional beta diversity was much lower, suggesting that species performing similar functions replace each other between sites. There were no differences in LCBD between management types or categories of landscape complexity, but the contributions of sites to beta diversity decreased as the percentage cover of olive groves increased. Species richness was also important in explaining variation in LCBD as species-poor sites tended to contribute the most to the local-to- regional beta diversity. However, some farms displayed high values of LCBD due to the existence of a high replacement component, indicating that some species recorded in these sites were scarce elsewhere. The indicator species analyses of biodiversity in this agro-forestry system. Main conclusions: Our results show that agricultural expansion promotes biotic homogenization and exemplify how the identification of both keystone species and communities can represent a powerful tool for the management of anthropized landscapes, Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Persistence of Seed Dispersal in Agroecosystems: Effects of Landscape Modification and Intensive Soil Management Practices in Avian Frugivores, Frugivory and Seed Deposition in Olive Croplands

  • Rey, Pedro J.
  • Camacho, Francisco M.
  • Tarifa, Rubén
  • Martínez-Núñez, Carlos
  • Salido, Teresa
  • Pérez, Antonio J.
  • García, Daniel
Farming impacts animal-mediated seed dispersal through mechanisms operating on at least two spatial scales. First, at the landscape scale, through habitat loss and land conversion to agriculture/livestock grazing, and second, at the farm scale, via a local intensification of agricultural practices. These two scales of farming impact seed dispersal function but have rarely been integrated. In particular, studies evaluating the effect of agriculture on the seed dispersal function of frugivorous birds in Mediterranean ecosystems are lacking. This study evaluates the role of landscape transformation, from fruit-rich woodland habitats to olive grove landscapes, together with local intensive practices of soil management on the persistence of the seed dispersal function for Mediterranean fleshy-fruited plants in olive landscapes of south Spain. We used bird censuses, mist-nets, and seed traps to characterize avian frugivore assemblages, frugivory, and seed deposition in the seminatural woodland habitat (SNWH) patches and olive fields of 40 olives farms spanning 20 localities distributed across the whole range of olive cultivation in Andalusia (southern Spain). We found that despite the remarkable dispersal function of olive grove landscapes, avian frugivore abundance and diversity, frugivory, and seed arrival decreased in olive fields compared to SNWH patches. Likewise, SNWH cover loss and/or olive growing expansion decreased avian frugivory and seed arrival. Interestingly, the habitat effects in the olive farms often depended on the landscape context. In particular, less diverse fruit-eating bird assemblages pooled in SNWH patches as olive grove cover increased or SNWH decreased in the landscape, while remaining relatively invariant in the olive fields. Finally, compared to conventional intensive agriculture, low-intensity management increased frugivory and seed deposition. We conclude that olive fields are less permeable to frugivores than expected due to the agroforest-like nature of these landscapes and that the presence of SNWH patches is crucial for the maintenance of frugivory and seed dispersal in agricultural landscapes. These results evidence that woodland habitat loss by olive expansion and intensive practices seriously threaten the dispersal service in olive-dominated landscapes. Maintenance, restoration, and promotion of woodland patches should be prioritized for the conservation of seed dispersal service and for enhancing the functional connectivity in human-shaped olive landscapes., This study was funded by the projects AGRABIES (CGL2015-68963-C2 funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033/ FEDER Una manera de hacer Europa) and RECOVECOS (PID2019-108332GB-I00, MICIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033). It was conducted under the general framework and associated farms of the LIFE Program project OLIVARES VIVOS (ref. LIFE14 NAT/ES/001094). CM-N received a grant as part of the FPI fellowship (BES-2016-078736) of the National Research Plan. DG was awarded a grant by the project ClaveSER (044-2019; Fundación BBVA).
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Research data Set de datos (Dataset)

Floral visitor-plant interactions in flowering patches of olive orchards from Andalusia

  • Cano, Domingo
  • Pérez, Antonio J.
  • Rey, Pedro J.
[Detailed methodology] We sampled the flower-visitor interactions in paired olive farms located in Andalusia. The surveys were carried out in 24 paired olive farms in 2020. On the one hand, each paired olive farm is constituted by an olive farm with low-intensive herb cover management and an olive farm with intensive herb cover management. The low-intensive management consists of the maintenance of herb cover during most of the year being only removed in late spring by mechanic mowing or cattle. Conversely, intensive management consists of removing the herb cover permanently by using pre-emergence and/ or post-emergence herbicides sometimes in combination with ploughing the ground several times a year. On the other hand, each paired farm in each locality is surrounded by the same landscape complexity. We classified each paired farm into three categories of landscape complexity (simple, intermediate, and complex) according to the proportion of semi-natural area estimated within a 2 km radius buffer around the centroid of each pair of farms. Surveys were conducted in multi-specific floral stands. We selected two 10 m2 multi-floral stands per olive farm located inside the olive orchard matrix. They were carried out monthly from March to June for 2020 (3 sampling rounds in total), matching the peak flowering period of the ground herb cover. Sampling consisted of recording the abundance and diversity of plant-floral visitor interactions in each floral patch for 15 minutes in the morning (until 13 h) and for 15 minutes in the afternoon (until 17 h) every sampling round., [Description of methods used for collection/generation of data] We sampled the flower-visitor interactions in paired olive farms located in Andalusia. The surveys were carried out in 24 paired olive farms in 2020. On the one hand, each paired olive farm is constituted by an olive farm with low-intensive herb cover management and an olive farm with intensive herb cover management. The low-intensive management consists of the maintenance of herb cover during most of the year being only removed in late spring by mechanic mowing or cattle. Conversely, intensive management consists of removing the herb cover permanently by using pre-emergence and/ or post-emergence herbicides sometimes in combination with ploughing the ground several times a year. On the other hand, each paired farm in each locality is surrounded by the same landscape complexity. We classified each paired farm in three categories of landscape complexity (simple, intermediate, and complex) according to the proportion of semi-natural area estimated within a 2 km radius buffer around the centroid of each pair of farms. Surveys were conducted in multi-specific floral stands. We selected two 10 m2 multi-floral stands per olive farm located inside the olive orchard matrix. They were carried out monthly from March to June for 2020 (3 sampling rounds in total), matching the peak flowering period of the ground herb cover. Sampling consisted of recording the abundance and diversity of plant-floral visitor interactions in each floral patch for 15 minutes in the morning (until 13 h) and for 15 minutes in the afternoon (until 17 h) every sampling round., Our aim was to assess the effect of agricultural management and landscape context of olive orchard on the topology of plant-flower visitor networks., Field work was funded by Proyecto RECOVECOS (PID2019-108332GB-I00, funded by MICIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033) and OLIVARES VIVOS (LIFE14 NAT/ES/001094, European Commission). Insect determination, final compilation and data processing were further funded by FEDER SUMHAL Work Package 9. Task 9.3.2. Model impact of land use change - Sustainability for Mediterranean Hotspots in Andalusia integrating LifeWatch ERIC (SUMHAL, LIFEWATCH-2019-09-CSIC-4, POPE 2014-2020; MICINN through European Regional Development Fund). CSIC is acknowledged for supporting Open Access publication., Please, see Metadata_ Plant_Floral_Visitor_interactions.csv file. Descripción del contenido de los ficheros: Plant_Floral_Visitor_Interaction_Data.csv [shows the summary of plant-floral visitor interactions per olive farm].-- DB_ Plant_Floral_Visitor_interactions_Sampling_Info.csv [file has information about the geographic location and samplings of each olive farm].-- Metadata_ Plant_Floral_Visitor_interactions.csv [records information about the meaning of columns in “Data_Plant-Insect_Interac.csv” and “Sampling_Info.csv”]., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Intensive ground cover management and landscape simplification affect community-wide floral visitor-plant interactions in olive groves

  • Cano, Domingo
  • Martínez-Núñez, Carlos
  • Pérez, Antonio J.
  • Alcántara, Julio M.
  • Salido, Teresa
  • Rey, Pedro J.
Plant-pollinator interaction networks can provide insights about the impacts of agricultural practices on biodiversity. However, studies on the agricultural impact on these networks most often focus on specific pollinator guilds (i.e., wild bees), hindering our understanding of the effects at the entire insect visitor community level. Here, we evaluated the impact of intensive agriculture and the moderation effects of landscape context on the topology of community-wide plant-visitor interaction networks (381 insect species). We also compared the responses of wild bee-based networks and community-wide plant-floral visitor networks to agricultural intensification to examine whether the former can be a good proxy of the latter. To this aim, we sampled plant-pollinator interaction networks in 24 paired olive farms with contrasting herb cover management (low-intensity management, where ground herb cover is not removed during the flowering season, and intensive management, with herbs persistently removed by herbicides and/or recurrent tillage) across a gradient of landscape complexity in Andalusia (Spain). Results show that the topology of whole floral visitor interaction networks was affected by the herb cover management and the landscape simplification. Furthermore, we found that the effects of the herb cover management were often moderated through the interaction with the landscape context at both floral stand and landscape scale. However, the landscape scale at which these interaction effects occurred varied with the network metric. Non-bee floral visitors were fundamentally redundant for the network topology. We concluded that the implementation of low-intensity management of ground covers in olive groves, together with the enhancement of the flower stands at the local level (e.g., floral strips) and the maintenance and/or restoration of semi-natural habitats at the large landscape scale, would be beneficial to the preservation of healthy and robust floral visitor communities. Our study further supports that wild-bee based interaction networks may adequately reflect the response of the entire networks of plant-floral visitor, at least in this study, We thank the owners of the olive orchards that granted us access to their properties. This work is part of the projects RECOVECOS (PID2019-108332GB-I00, funded by MICIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033) and OLIVARES VIVOS + (LIFE20 AT/ES/001487, European Commission). Participation of AJP in pollinator and flower censuses and data curation was funded by MICINN through European Regional Development Fund [SUMHAL, LIFEWATCH-2019-09-CSIC-4, POPE 2014-2020]. D.C. was granted a predoctoral fellowship (FPU17/02186). CMN was supported by a "Juan de la Cierva” postdoctoral grant (ref. FJC2021-046829-I)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Woodland loss differently affects seed dispersal by resident and migratory avian frugivores in olive grove-dominated landscapes

  • Tarifa, Rubén
  • González-Varo, Juan P.
  • Camacho, Francisco M.
  • Pérez, Antonio J.
  • Salido, Teresa
  • Rey, Pedro J.
Seed dispersal by frugivores is a key ecological process underpinning the functionality of woodland patches and their capacity to maintain biodiversity in agricultural landscapes. Resident and migratory avian frugivores differ in temporal span of their local occurrence, as well as in mobility and territoriality. However, whether landscape homogenization by agriculture affects seed dispersal by avian frugivores differing in migratory strategy remains largely unexplored. We hypothesized a positive role of woodland patches on avian frugivore abundance and seed-dispersal frequency, and a differential impact of woodland loss and landscape simplification on resident and migratory frugivorous birds. We tested these hypotheses in 20 farms distributed along a gradient of woodland loss and olive cropland expansion in south Spain, considering woodland patches and olive fields as two habitats to survey avian frugivore abundance and frequency of seed dispersal. We confirmed that both the abundance and seed-dispersal frequency of avian frugivores were higher in woodland patches than in olive fields, and also that both decayed with decreasing woodland cover. This was largely mediated by a few European (winter) migrants and secondarily by some resident species. However, the woodland patches were unable to intercept sub-Saharan (summer) migrants in sufficient numbers as to make their contribution to dispersal of summer fruits meaningful. Woodland patches with higher seed-dispersal function were located predominantly in landscapes with high woodland cover and/or fruit availability. Moreover, a relatively high woodland cover in the landscape enhanced the seed dispersal function in woodland patches through a balance between high overall frugivore abundance and dispersal frequency, and some increased activity of resident and summer migrants. Our results also inform that the presence of particularly fruit-rich woodland patches can compensate the woodland cover required to maintain the function by enhancing the frequency of seed dispersal of all migratory groups. In contrast, to maintain the function of fruit-poor woodlands their cover at landscape scale should increase. Preserving and restoring woodland patches at landscape scale and enhancing their abundance and diversity of fruits could boost the activity of different disperser groups and their functional complementarity across agricultural landscapes., This study was funded by the projects OLIVARES VIVOS+(LIFE20 NAT/ES/001487) of the European Commission and RECOVECOS (PID2019-108332GB-I00, MICIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033). During the manuscript elaboration, RT received additional financial support from JPGV through a Spanish 'Ramón y Cajal' grant (RYC-2017-22095)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Threshold responses of birds to agricultural intensification in Mediterranean olive groves

  • García-Navas, Vicente
  • Tarifa, Rubén
  • Salido, Teresa
  • González-Robles, Ana
  • López-Orta, A.
  • Valera, Francisco
  • Rey, Pedro J.
Olive groves are the most representative crop of the Mediterranean basin. This agroforestry system is undergoing a strong transformation in recent decades as a result of the agricultural intensification process prevailing in the Northern Hemisphere. Although some authors have suggested that farmland biodiversity responds non-linearly to the complexity of agricultural landscapes, few studies have used community thresholds to identify potential tipping points. Here, we examined the existence of synchronous responses in bird abundance across a gradient of decreasing agricultural intensification in Spanish olive groves. Our study system comprised 25 sites, each consisting of a pair of farms: one with intensive management and the other one with extensive management of the herbaceous cover. We explored whether bird abundances exhibit non-linear threshold responses to ant abundance and tree density at a local (field) scale, plant diversity (both herbaceous and woody plants) at a local (farm) scale, and to proportion of natural habitat at a landscape scale using Threshold Indicator Taxa ANalysis (TITAN). We found a higher incidence of positive responses with decreasing levels of intensification, and these were not restricted to certain guilds or avian families. Few indicator species showed a significant negative response. Thresholds detected were not sharp but rather gradual changes along the environmental gradients. Although they do not necessarily support evidence of ecological thresholds characterized by rapid changes in species abundance or distribution, these patterns can help identify optimal change points for management decisions. Specifically, our results indicate that reaching a minimum threshold of ~85 and 15 species of herbaceous and woody plants, respectively, per unit of surface can entail a gain in terms of bird diversity for olive farms with virtually no detrimental effects. Overall, this study shows that the adoption of agri-environmental measures like the maintenance of ground cover and patches of natural habitat has a positive impact on different species inhabiting this woody crop, and this effect occurs at different spatial scales., This study was funded by the projects “Olivares Vivos” (LIFE14 NAT/ES/001094) and “Olivares Vivos+” (LIFE20 NAT/ES/001487) of the Life Program of the European Commission, and the project RECOVECOS (PID2019-108332GB-I00) from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation-EU. Vicente García-Navas was supported by a Ramón y Cajal program from Agencia Estatal de Investigación (RYC2019-026703-I)., Peer reviewed
DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Agricultural intensification indirectly reshapes bee-plant interaction networks through shifts in bee functional traits

  • Cano, Domingo
  • Martínez-Núñez, Carlos
  • Moreno-Pérez, Antonio J.
  • Alcántara, Julio M.
  • Moretti, Marco
  • Salido, Teresa
  • Rey, Pedro J.
High-intensity farming can lead to non-random local extinctions and functional filtering of pollinating insect assemblages, disproportionately harming species with certain traits. This process can ultimately reshape pollinator-plant interaction networks in predictable, consistent manners, although this pathway remains largely unexplored. Here, we investigate how agricultural intensification affects the structure of bee-plant interaction networks both directly and indirectly by influencing the functional composition and diversity (in terms of foraging and nesting traits) of the bee assemblages. We considered 24 paired olive farms with contrasting management over a gradient of landscape complexity. We characterized the network structure and functional composition of bee assemblages visiting floral patches in the olive fields by using both functional identity and diversity metrics. We then built Bayesian multilevel models to assess the direct and indirect (via functional filtering processes) effects of agricultural intensification on network properties. We found that most of the effects of agricultural intensification on bee-plant network properties in floral patches occur through the filtering of the bee functional traits. However, while the effects of farming practices occur fundamentally through the filtering of foraging traits, the landscape effects occur via the modification of the nesting guilds. High-intensity herb cover management negatively affected larger bees (also highly correlated with longer proboscis), resulting in a decrease in the overlap of bees' interaction niches. This filtering was mitigated in flowering patches with higher floral cover, which increased the functional diversity of bees, ultimately reducing the overlap of the plants' interaction niches. In turn, the loss of semi-natural habitats in the landscape disproportionately favored ground excavators, causing homogenization of nesting guild composition. This, coupled with decreased floral abundance (patch scale), led to less diverse and structurally simpler networks. In conclusion, our study suggests that agricultural intensification reshapes bee-plant networks in olive landscapes through functional filtering of bee assemblages and provides cues to mitigate these effects. On a small scale, floral patches with abundant flowers buffer the filtering of bees' foraging traits, suggesting that well-managed flower patches help mitigate the functional depletion imposed by agricultural intensification. Meanwhile, favoring semi-natural remnants at a large scale attenuates the homogenization of nesting guild composition., This work is part of the projects RECOVECOS (PID2019-108332GB-I00, funded by MICIN/AEI/https://doi.org/10.13039/501100011033) and OLIVARES VIVOS + (LIFE20 AT/ES/001487, European Commission). Participation of Antonio J. Pérez in pollinator and flower censuses and data curation was funded by MICINN through European Regional Development Fund (SUMHAL, LIFEWATCH-2019-09-CSIC-4, POPE 2014-2020). Domingo Cano was granted a predoctoral fellowship (FPU17/02186). Carlos Martínez-Núñez was supported by a “Juan de la Cierva” postdoctoral grant (ref. FJC2021-046829-I)., Peer reviewed