Skip to main content

METAFISICA DE LA BIOLOGIA: PROCESOS Y DISPOSICIONES

PID2021-127184NB-I00

•
Funding agency name Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Funding agency acronym AEI
Program Programa Estatal para Impulsar la Investigación Científico-Técnica y su Transferencia
Subprogram Subprograma Estatal de Generación de Conocimiento
Call Proyectos de I+D+i (Generación de Conocimiento y Retos Investigación)
Call year 2021
State Plan 2021-2023 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Beneficiary centre UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE DE MADRID

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 2
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A democratic science in an unequal world? The challenge of climate denialism for the new demarcation problem

  • Cuadrado Bastos, Carolina
  • Nuño, Laura
This paper explores the question of when the influence of values is legitimate in climate change research. Using the case of climatologist John Christy as a focal point, we examine how climate-skeptic research, which challenges the consensus on anthropogenic global warming, has been shaped by non-epistemic values. These values have influenced both his scientific decisions and his political stances, ultimately impacting U.S. climate policies. The analysis addresses the broader challenge of the "new demarcation problem"—distinguishing legitimate from illegitimate values in scientific research—and evaluates two proposed solutions: the epistemic priority and the aims approach. We argue that while the aims approach provides a more effective framework for managing the influence of values in climate science, democratic value-management risks reproducing social and geographical inequalities in scientific decision-making. To address these limitations, we propose an engaged aims approach that integrates political restrictions related to climate justice, offering a more equitable framework for managing values in climate research., JAE Intro 2022 Institute of Philosophy, Spanish National Research Council (IFS-CSIC). JAEINT_22_00649., FPU 2022 (Ministry of Universities) FPU22/02058., Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (Project ID PID2021-127184NB-I00)., Peer reviewed
Docta Complutense
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

From the method of division to the theory of transformations: Thompson after Aristotle, and Aristotle after Thompson, Del método de la división a la teoría de las transformaciones: Thomson según Aristóteles y Aristóteles según Thompson

  • Nuño De La Rosa García, Laura
  • Lennox, James G.
Aristotle’s influence on D’Arcy Thompson was praised by Thompson himself and has been recognized by others in various respects, including the aesthetic and normative dimensions of biology, and the multicausal explanation of living forms. This article focuses on the relatedness of organic forms, one of the core problems addressed by both Aristotle’s History of Animals (HA), and the renowned chapter of Thompson’s On Growth and Form (G&F), “On the Theory of Transformations, or the Comparison of Related Forms.” We contend that, far from being an incidental inspiration stemming from Thompson’s classicist background, his translation of HA played a pivotal role in developing his theory of transformations. Furthermore, we argue that Thompson’s interpretation of the Aristotelian method of comparison challenges the prevailing view of Aristotle as the founder of “typological essentialism,” and is a key episode in the revision of this narrative. Thompson understood that the method Aristotle used in HA to compare animal forms is better comprehended as a “method of transformations,” leading to a morphological arrangement of animal diversity, as opposed to a taxonomical classification. Finally, we examine how this approach to the relatedness of forms lay the foundation for a causal understanding of parts and their interconnections. Although Aristotle and Thompson emphasized distinct types of causes, we contend that they both differ in a fundamental sense from the one introduced by Darwin’s theory of natural selection, which was formulated as a solution to the species problem rather than the form problem. We conclude that Thompson’s interpretation of Aristotle’s approach to form comparison has not only impacted contemporary scholarship on Aristotle’s biology, but revitalized a perspective that has regained significance due to the resurgence of the problem of form in evo-devo.