Skip to main content

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 4
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Steering committee management. Expertise, diversity, and decision-making structures

  • Sáenz-Royo, Carlos
  • Chiclana, Francisco
  • Herrera-Viedma, Enrique
This paper proposes to analyze how the differences in expertise, diversity, and group decision procedures affect the quality of the strategic decision of steering committees. Strategic decisions are difficult to anticipate, and performances of the alternatives are often not observable in their entirety, which prevent researchers from obtaining controlled empirical studies. This paper proposes to analyze the performance of steering committees where managers can err in their decisions using the Intentional Bounded Rationality (IBR). The majority procedure improves the committee's performance concerning authority when the level of diversity and expertise increases. However, in situations of low expertise, the gains over authority narrow. This work provides guidance in terms of trade-offs between the mentality of managers, their expertise, group decision procedures, and diversity, which in the empirical works are contradictory. This study contributes to current theorizations of committee management using the IBR methodology, which is new and allows quantifying the contribution of the distinct characteristics of the committee.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Ordering vs. AHP. Does the intensity used in the decision support techniques compensate?

  • Sáenz-Royo, Carlos
  • Chiclana, Francisco
  • Herrera-Viedma, Enrique
The manifestation of the intensity in the judgment of one alternative versus another in the peer comparison processes is a central element in some decision support techniques, such as the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP). However, its contribution regarding quality (expected performance) with respect to the priority vector has not been evaluated so far. Using the Intentional Bounded Rationality Methodology (IBRM), this work analyzes the gains obtained from requiring the decision-maker to report an intensity judgment in pairs (AHP) with respect to a technique that only requires expressing a preference (Ordering). The results show that when decision-makers have low levels of expertise, it is possible that a less informative and computational cheap technique (Ordering) performs better than a more informative and computational expensive one (AHP). When decision-makers have medium and high levels of expertise, AHP technique obtains modest gains with respect to the Ordering technique. This study proposes a cost-benefit analysis of decision support techniques contrasting the gains of a technique that requires more resources (AHP) against other that require less resources (Ordering). Our results can change the managing approach of the information obtained from experts’ judgments.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Authority and consensus in group decision making with fallible individuals

  • Sáenz-Royo, C.
  • Salas-Fumás, V.
  • Lozano-Rojo, Á.
This paper compares the performance, in terms of expected opportunity loss of mistakes, of group decision making with fallible members, under different organization structures. These structures result from combining the decision mechanisms of authority and consensus with the communication networks of star, tree, and full network. Simulation results from Agent Based Modeling show that the authority (consensus) is preferred when the time to reach a group decision matters (not matters), and in organizational environments of high (low) risk and high (low) prospects of growth. Additionally, the results of the paper recommend that organizations that want to migrate from authority to consensus decision making, as defined here, should switch from the low-density tree like connecting network, common in hierarchical structures, to a high-density full network.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publication Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Divide and conquer? A combination of judgments method for comparing DSSs. Pairwise comparison vs. holistic paradigms

  • Sáenz-Royo, Carlos
  • Chiclana, Francisco
Despite the prevalence of Decision Support Systems (DSSs) in the field of decision-making, there is a paucity of research dedicated to the evaluation and comparison of these systems. This paper put forward a novel approach to symbolically encoding a DSS, which enables the generalization of comparisons between DSSs for any distribution of performances of the alternatives. The only hypothesis required in the proposed methodology is that the probability of choosing each alternative is proportional to its latent performance. The approach developed is demonstrated with its application to compare two paradigms commonly employed in DSS: holistic versus pairwise. Using a set of three alternatives, the present study provides mathematical proof that a DSS based on the pairwise comparison paradigm achieves higher expected performance than a DSS based on the holistic evaluation paradigm. This result challenges the emerging preference for holistic evaluation of alternatives and suggests that this result may apply to any number of alternatives.