e_Buah Biblioteca Digital Universidad de Alcalá
Publication
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
Challenges in accurate HDV RNA quantification: inter-assay variability and the impact of thermal shock
11 p., Quantitative RT-PCR (qRT-PCR) is essential for monitoring hepatitis delta
virus (HDV) RNA, yet assays lack standardization. We aimed to evaluate the performance
of three qRT-PCR assays and to assess the impact of a pre-analytical thermal shock
procedure. We conducted a comparative study using 206 samples (106 with anti-HDV
antibodies and 100 anti-HDV-negative as a control group), which were tested in parallel
with three qRT-PCR assays: Vircell, Certest, and Altona. Performance was evaluated
for inter-assay agreement (kappa index), quantitative correlation (R²), and bias (BlandAltman). Altona detected 56 HDV-RNA positive samples, whereas Vircell and Certest
detected 55 positive samples. Inter-assay agreement was perfect comparing Vircell vs
Certest (agreement = 100%, к = 1.000) and almost perfect comparing Altona with both
Vircell and Certest (agreement = 99.5%, к = 0.988). Quantitatively, Vircell and Certest
assays showed relevant systematic biases compared to Altona, overestimating viral loads
by approximately 0.24 log10 International Units (IU)/mL (Certest) and 0.33 log10 IU/mL
(Vircell). The correlation with Altona was strong for Certest (R² = 0.864) and moderate for
Vircell (R² = 0.793), while the correlation between Certest and Vircell was weaker (R² =
0.720). Thermal shock improved sensitivity in one case (Certest vs Vircell) but increased
quantitative variability, worsening the inter-assay correlation (R² = 0.684). In conclusion,
all three assays were highly concordant for the qualitative diagnosis of HDV infection,
but their quantitative biases prevent their interchangeable use for treatment monitoring.
Thermal shock is not recommended for routine monitoring, as a significant compromise
in quantitative accuracy and precision outweighs any potential gains in sensitivity., European Society of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases, Instituto de Salud Carlos III, Centro de Investigación en Red en Enfermedades Infecciosas, Fundación para la Investigación Biomédica del Hospital Universitario Príncipe de Asturias