Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 5
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Pricing instruments in environmental and climate policy when polluters are boundedly rational

  • Gsottbauer, Elisabeth
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
The use of pricing instruments in environmental policy has been argued to have certain advantages, notably related to static and dynamic efficiency as well as effectiveness due to economy-wide scope. This paper adopts a broad perspective to provide a complete set of arguments in favour of price-based instruments in environmental policy, illustrated for climate policy. Pricing instruments are still not used to their full potential. The reason is that there is still considerable unfounded scepticism, including by researchers in the social environmental sciences, about their functioning and performance. Different disciplines express distinct and partly inconsistent ideas on the desirability of pricing instruments. An important recent criticism is that traditional economic arguments for pricing instruments are based on rational agents and are inconsistent with findings of behavioural economics. We examine this argument by assessing how instruments behave under various realistic behavioural assumptions in line with bounded rationality and other-regarding behaviour. We find that the case is strengthened for cap-and-trade versus environmental taxation. We also discuss additional instruments to effectively counter environmental and climate challenges under bounded rationality and social interactions.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Comparing two court rulings on Shell's carbon emissions with climate-policy science

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Van Soest, Jan Paul|||0000-0002-5082-7650
In November 2024, a ruling by a Dutch Court of Appeal overturned a 2021 District Court verdict concerning the obligations of the oil and gas company Shell to reduce its carbon emissions. This perspective article examines the scientific basis of the differing arguments in the two court rulings, with a particular focus on the effectiveness of emissions-reduction strategies. To this end, we first summarize the reasoning in both rulings and identify their key points of divergence. Subsequently, we assess which ruling aligns more closely with the scientific literature on climate policy. Our analysis zooms in on four issues: the public-good nature of climate mitigation and the problem of free-riding; the aim and impact of the European Union's Emissions Trading System; the treatment of Scope 3 emissions generated by end users of Shell's products; and the roles of companies versus the state in achieving emissions reductions. We conclude that the Court of Appeal's ruling is more consistent with current scientific insights about effective climate policy than the earlier District Court decision. This is not to deny that companies like Shell will have to fundamentally transform - or otherwise eventually disappear - on the path to a zero-carbon economy. But such change is most likely to occur as the outcome of a systemic policy approach that delivers steady and substantial emissions reductions across all sectors and jurisdictions. We therefore argue that a more effective legal strategy is to pursue legal action against governments that fail to implement policies in line with internationally agreed climate targets.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

'Beyond GDP' Requires Replacement, Not Just Additional Metrics

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Political decision-making remains dominated by GDP, often at the expense of social and environmental concerns. Indicator dashboards have so far had limited impact on core policy decisions in this regard. This article argues that only replacing GDP with a comprehensive aggregate metric can overcome its dominance. To illustrate which alternative is most likely to succeed, the concept of "perception distance" (or similarity) to GDP is introduced, formalized and compared across key options. Furthermore, it is argued that replacing GDP with a superior aggregate metric will enhance the effectiveness of the additive approach as the new headline metric reduces tension with disaggregate domain indicators for wellbeing, inequality and sustainability.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The Paradox of Climate Justice

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Climate justice has gained increasing prominence in both public discourse and the academic literature. This reflects a shift in how climate change is understood, from primarily an environmental issue to a deeply social challenge. While ensuring a minimal degree of equity in the distribution of climate policy impacts is crucial for stable political support in democratic societies, it remains unclear whether win- win solutions can be achieved universally-or even in many instances. This paper argues that ambitious climate justice goals may inadvertently reduce support for policies capable of substantially cutting emissions. This could result in greater long- term intra- and intergenerational injustice due to insufficient climate action. To explore this paradox, the paper examines how the interplay between justice, effectiveness of emissions reduction, and political feasibility plays out across specific climate policy instruments. To this end, it compares mainstream and heterodox strategies, with a focus on distributive justice. Many heterodox proposals turn out to face challenges in terms of political feasibility and systemic impact-often relying more on pull than push mechanisms and being vulnerable to rebound effects. Certain mainstream instruments appear better positioned to balance the three criteria. How the trade- off plays out when combining mainstream and heterodox instruments in a policy mix remains largely unexplored. The paper concludes by outlining a research agenda to advance our understanding of these issues.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Assessing criticisms of carbon pricing

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Botzen, W. J. Wouter|||0000-0002-8563-4963
There is still considerable resistance against carbon pricing - i.e. carbon taxation or cap-and-trade - in the social and policy sciences. We review its main arguments and conclude that they are not supported by the theoretical and empirical literature on instrument performance. Critics are also unable to offer alternative and feasible instruments that limit free riding in climate solutions and perform better on main evaluation criteria, namely effectiveness, efficiency, equity, and global-harmonization potential. Their argument that carbon pricing meets strong political resistance is countered by its widespread implementation already and by its ability to compensate inequitable impacts. We argue that overcoming unsubstantiated criticism on carbon pricing will lead to more consistent advice from policy experts to politicians, thus improving the feasibility of, and accelerating progress towards, globally harmonized and stringent climate policy. All in all, it might be more widely acknowledged that the remarkable feature of carbon pricing is that, if well implemented, it has a great number of advantages and few disadvantages. Rather than weakening political support by criticizing carbon pricing, critics would contribute more productively to effective global climate policy by defending proper and uniform implementation of it.