Pasar al contenido principal

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 59
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Carbon tax acceptability with information provision and mixed revenue uses

  • Maestre Andrés, Sara|||0000-0003-3971-5209
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Public acceptability of carbon taxation depends on its revenue use. Which single or mixed revenue use is most appropriate, and which perceptions of policy effectiveness and fairness explain this, remains unclear. It is, moreover, uncertain how people's prior knowledge about carbon taxation affects policy acceptability. Here we conduct a survey experiment to test how distinct revenue uses, prior knowledge, and information provision about the functioning of carbon taxation affect policy perceptions and acceptability. We show that spending revenues on climate projects maximises acceptability as well as perceived fairness and effectiveness. A mix of different revenue uses is also popular, notably compensating low-income households and funding climate projects. In addition, we find that providing information about carbon taxation increases acceptability for unspecified revenue use and for people with more prior tax knowledge. Furthermore, policy acceptability is more strongly related to perceived fairness than to perceived effectiveness.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evolutionary macroeconomic assessment of employment and innovation impacts of climate policy packages

  • Rengs, Bernhard
  • Scholz-Wäckerle, Manuel|||0000-0002-3137-1782
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Climate policy has been mainly studied with economic models that assume representative, rational agents. Such policy aims, though, at changing carbon-intensive consumption and production patterns driven by bounded rationality and other-regarding preferences, such as status and imitation. To examine climate policy under such alternative behavioral assumptions, we develop a model tool by adapting an existing general-purpose macroeconomic multi-agent model. The resulting tool allows testing various climate policies in terms of combined climate and economic performance. The model is particularly suitable to address the distributional impacts of climate policies, not only because populations of many agents are included, but also as these are composed of different classes of households. The approach accounts for two types of innovations, which improve either the carbon or labor intensity of production. We simulate policy scenarios with distinct combinations of carbon taxation, a reduction of labor taxes, subsidies for green innovation, a price subsidy to consumers for less carbon-intensive products, and green government procurement. The results show pronounced differences with those obtained by rational-agent model studies. It turns out that a supply-oriented subsidy for green innovation, funded by the revenues of a carbon tax, results in a significant reduction of carbon emissions without causing negative effects on employment. On the contrary, demand-oriented subsidies for adopting greener technologies, funded in the same manner, result in either none or considerably less reduction of carbon emissions and may even lead to higher unemployment. Our study also contributes insight on a potential double dividend of shifting taxes from labor to carbon.
Dipòsit Digital de la UB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A dual-track transition to global carbon pricing: the glass is half full

  • Bergh, Jeroen C. J. M. van den
  • Angelsen, Arild
  • Baranzini, Andrea
  • Botzen, W. J. Wouter
  • Carattini, Stefano
  • Drews, Stefan
  • Dunlop, Tessa
  • Galbraith, Eric D.
  • Howarth, Richard B.
  • Padilla Rosa, Emilio
  • Roca Jusmet, Jordi
  • Schmidt, Robert
We appreciate the response by Erik Haites (2020) to our paper (van den Bergh et al., 2020a), not only because it is well-informed and contains many subtle remarks, but also because our article was aimed at stimulating debate on how to achieve effective climate policies that limit global warming change to 1.5-2°C. There is no question that the latter represents a tremendous challenge for the global community, and our dual-track proposal is intended to provide a workable approach to it by addressing the free-riding problem through policy harmonization. Although we feel that Haites raises many relevant points regarding the difficulties of carrying out the proposal, most of these were, in fact, already addressed by our paper (...)
Dipòsit Digital de la UB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A dual-track transition to global carbon pricing

  • Bergh, Jeroen C. J. M. van den
  • Angelsen, Arild
  • Baranzini, Andrea
  • Botzen, W. J. Wouter
  • Carattini, Stefano
  • Drews, Stefan
  • Dunlop, Tessa
  • Galbraith, Eric D.
  • Howarth, Richard B.
  • Padilla Rosa, Emilio
  • Roca Jusmet, Jordi
  • Schmidt, Robert
Unilateral climate policies have been unable to achieve intended emissions reductions. We argue that international harmonization of climate policy beyond the Paris Agreement is the only way forward and that global carbon pricing, either through a tax or market, is the best available instrument to manage this. A foundation has already been laid, as current carbon pricing initiatives cover about 20% of global CO2 emissions. Since it limits free-riding by countries/jurisdictions, global carbon pricing is, in principle, behaviourally easier to negotiate than other instruments, such as emission targets or technical standards.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A dual-track transition to global carbon pricing

  • Bergh, Jeroen C. J. M. van den
  • Angelsen, Arild
  • Baranzini, Andrea
  • Botzen, W. J. Wouter
  • Carattini, Stefano
  • Drews, Stefan
  • Dunlop, Tessa
  • Galbraith, Eric D.
  • Howarth, Richard B.
  • Padilla Rosa, Emilio
  • Roca Jusmet, Jordi
  • Schmidt, Robert
Unilateral climate policies have been unable to achieve intended emissions reductions. We argue that international harmonization of climate policy beyond the Paris Agreement is the only way forward and that global carbon pricing, either through a tax or market, is the best available instrument to manage this. A foundation has already been laid, as current carbon pricing initiatives cover about 20% of global CO2 emissions. Since it limits free-riding by countries/jurisdictions, global carbon pricing is, in principle, behaviourally easier to negotiate than other instruments, such as emission targets or technical standards.
Recercat. Dipósit de la Recerca de Catalunya
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A dual-track transition to global carbon pricing: the glass is half full

  • Bergh, Jeroen C. J. M. van den
  • Angelsen, Arild
  • Baranzini, Andrea
  • Botzen, W. J. Wouter
  • Carattini, Stefano
  • Drews, Stefan
  • Dunlop, Tessa
  • Galbraith, Eric D.
  • Howarth, Richard B.
  • Padilla Rosa, Emilio
  • Roca Jusmet, Jordi
  • Schmidt, Robert
We appreciate the response by Erik Haites (2020) to our paper (van den Bergh et al., 2020a), not only because it is well-informed and contains many subtle remarks, but also because our article was aimed at stimulating debate on how to achieve effective climate policies that limit global warming change to 1.5-2°C. There is no question that the latter represents a tremendous challenge for the global community, and our dual-track proposal is intended to provide a workable approach to it by addressing the free-riding problem through policy harmonization. Although we feel that Haites raises many relevant points regarding the difficulties of carrying out the proposal, most of these were, in fact, already addressed by our paper (...)
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Opinion clusters in academic and public debates on growth-vs-environment

  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
The debate about the relationship between economic growth and environmental sustainability involves many dimensions as well as much diversity in terminology. While it is often summarized in terms of dichotomous pro- and anti-growth positions, several studies indicate that additional views exist, and that these may differ between experts and the general public. The objective of this paper is to identify and analyze segments of the scientific and general population with distinct views in this respect. To this end, we bring together two data sets: one from a nationally representative survey of the general public of Spain (N = 1004) and another from an international survey of researchers from various disciplinary backgrounds (N = 814). Using latent class analysis, we identify three similar segments in the two samples, labeled as Green growth, Agrowth and Degrowth. Overall, clusters are more consistent, better distinguishable on all constituent dimensions and more polarized in the scientific than public opinion survey. In addition, we find that diverging views on social issues are more strongly associated with distinct clusters in the public opinion sample, and on environmental issues in the scientific opinion sample.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Fossil fuel divestment and climate change, Reviewing contested arguments

  • Braungardt, Sibylle
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Dunlop, Tessa|||0000-0002-2265-9880
The strategy of fossil fuel divestment has attracted considerable attention in recent years, particularly in the press and social media. Spearheaded as a movement based on ethical principles, divestment has been suggested to play a potential role in shaping public opinion and policymaking on climate change. The growing size of the movement has prompted debate about the extent of its impact on fossil fuel companies and climate change mitigation efforts. This article investigates the potential effectiveness of the divestment movement according to the end goal of climate campaigners - to bring about a complete break from fossil fuels. We collect and qualify the key arguments as found mainly in the informal debate, and to a lesser extent in the academic literature. This will help readers to make an informed judgement that can contribute to a constructive debate about the effectiveness of divestment. We organize the literature into arguments for and against divestment, and explain how these relate to each other. In addition, we derive suggestions for further research on divestment.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evolution of opinions in the growth-vs-environment debate, extended replicator dynamics

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
The evolution of opinions in the long-standing debate on growth-versus-environment may affect support for important sustainability policies, in areas such as biodiversity loss, climate change, deforestation and freshwater scarcity. In order to understand this evolution, we develop a model describing the dynamics of four distinct opinions as identified in recent surveys, namely growth-at-all-cost, green growth, agrowth and degrowth. The model is based on modifying standard replicator dynamics to match a multi-group structure. Individuals are influenced by local or global interactions with others, based on adjacent opinion groups and exposure to information about environmental change. Psychological resistance to opinion change is also accounted for. The model is calibrated with recent survey data. Numerical analysis shows which opinions survive under particular conditions. We find, among others, that under local interactions, ultimate outcomes are characterized by lack of consensus, i.e. survival of multiple opinions. In addition, equal impacts of environmental change on opinions do not always translate in joint survival of associated opinions. Under worsening environmental conditions while continuing economic growth, opinions shift from green growth to agrowth and degrowth. Fostering global interactions among individuals, causing them to be influenced by a broad spectrum of opinions, makes consensus more likely. We also consider model dynamics if feedback from opinions to policy to environmental change and back is included. This confirms robustness of the results. It should be noted that the model is not meant to predict but to explore the consequences of combinations of assumptions about social networks, psychological mechanisms, environmental dynamics, and connections between opinion distribution and environmental policy. The study represents the first analysis of opinion dynamics in the growth-vs-environment debate and suggests a number of routes for further investigation.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Tackling the plastic problem, a review on perceptions, behaviors, and interventions

  • Heidbreder, Lea Marie
  • Babloka, Isabella
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Menzel, Claudia
The excessive production and consumption of plastic has serious consequences on the environment and human health. The reduction of plastic has therefore become a major global challenge. As technical solutions might be insufficient to curb the problem, a perspective highlighting the impact of human behavior is needed. The current literature review provides an overview of the existing social-scientific literature on plastic, ranging from risk awareness, consumers' preferences, and predictors of usage behavior to political and psychological intervention strategies. By reviewing the literature, we aim to identify potential factors for future interventions to reduce plastic consumption. The 187 studies reviewed show that people much appreciate and routinely use plastic, despite a pronounced awareness of the associated problems. Habits, norms, and situational factors seem to be especially predictive for plastic consumption behavior. Both political and psychological interventions are potentially effective, although long-term effects are often uncertain. The review closes with implications for behavior-based solutions and future research, which should combine interdisciplinary approaches and take into account cultural differences.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Perceived fairness and public acceptability of carbon pricing, a review of the literature

  • Maestre Andrés, Sara|||0000-0003-3971-5209
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
While carbon pricing is widely seen as a crucial element of climate policy and has been implemented in many countries, it also has met with strong resistance. We provide a comprehensive overview of public perceptions of the fairness of carbon pricing and how these affect policy acceptability. To this end, we review evidence from empirical studies on how individuals judge personal, distributional and procedural aspects of carbon taxes and cap-and-trade. In addition, we examine preferences for particular redistributive and other uses of revenues generated by carbon pricing and their role in instrument acceptability. Our results indicate a high concern over distributional effects, particularly in relation to policy impacts on poor people, in turn reducing policy acceptability. In addition, people show little trust in the capacities of governments to put the revenues of carbon pricing to good use. Somewhat surprisingly, most studies do not indicate clear public preferences for using revenues to ensure fairer policy outcomes, notably by reducing its regressive effects. Instead, many people prefer using revenues for 'environmental projects' of various kinds. We end by providing recommendations for improving public acceptability of carbon pricing. One suggestion to increase policy acceptability is combining the redistribution of revenue to vulnerable groups with the funding for environmental projects, such as on renewable energy.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Social reinforcement with weighted interactions

  • Konc, Théo|||0000-0002-0203-9473
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
The speed and extent of diffusion of behaviors in social networks depends on network structure and individual preferences. The contribution of the present study is twofold. First, we introduce weighted interactions between potential adopters that depend on the similarity in their preferences and moderate the strength of social reinforcement. The reason for the extension is the existence of a confirmation bias in the way agents treat information by prioritizing evidence conforming to their opinion. As a result, individuals become less likely to be influenced by peers with relatively different preferences, reducing the overall diffusion rate under clustered networks. Second, we enrich our analysis by also considering a scale free network topology with a high degree asymmetry, motivated by its pervasiveness in online social networks. This network performs consistently well in terms of diffusion for different parameter combinations and clearly outperforms clustered networks under weighted interactions. Our results show that more realistic assumptions regarding agents' interactions shift the focus from clustering to degree distribution in the study of network structures allowing for fast and widespread behavior adoption.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Global competition dynamics of fossil fuels and renewable energy under climate policies and peak oil: A behavioural model

  • Zeppini, Paolo
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
We develop a stochastic decision model to analyse the global competitive dynamics of fossil fuels and renewable energy. It describes coal, oil/gas, solar and wind. These differ not only in pollution intensities but also in profitability and innovation potential. The model accounts for the effect of learning curves, path-dependence and climate policies. Adoption shares endogenously affect agents' utility through increasing returns to adoption, learning, and a 'peak oil' capacity constraint. We find that peak oil induces a transition to coal rather than renewable energy, which worsens climate change. By introducing climate policies - such as a carbon tax, market adoption or R&D subsidies for renewables, and eliminating existing subsidies for fossil fuels - we identify potential transition patterns to a low-carbon energy system. Model analysis clarifies two main features of climate policies: which ones solve the climate problem, i.e. do not surpass the critical carbon budget; and how uncertain or variable are final market shares of energy sources.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Differences in CO2 emissions of solar PV production among technologies and regions: Application to China, EU and USA

  • Liu, Feng|||0000-0003-3383-7598
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
A widespread implicit assumption is that renewable energy options are approximately low-carbon. However, production and life cycles of such technologies tend to produce CO2 emissions. To minimize life-cycle emissions, one should account for such emissions and implement adequate policies to encourage innovation and adoption of well-performing technologies in this respect. We develop a framework to analyse this issue, grounded in the concepts of 'energy return on energy invested' (EROI) and 'net energy return on carbon invested' (EROC). Applying these to the main PV technologies and production regions - namely China, EU and USA - displays considerable discrepancies. We conditionally predict the development of average EROI and EROC over time under business-as-usual and low-carbon electricity generation scenarios. A main policy lesson is that without a systemic policy instrument, such as carbon pricing, incentives for low-carbon production of renewable energy options are too weak, which likely will delay a complete transition to a low-carbon economy.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo de revisión (ReviewArticle)

A review of agent-based modelling of climate-energy policy

  • Castro Santa, Juana|||0000-0002-6411-9460
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Exadaktylos, Filippos|||0000-0001-7339-8847
  • Foramitti, Joël|||0000-0002-4828-7288
  • Klein, Franziska|||0000-0001-6968-6213
  • Konc, Théo Aloïs Dimitri|||0000-0002-0203-9473
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Agent-based models (ABMs) have recently seen much application to the field of climate mitigation policies. They offer a more realistic description of micro behaviour than traditional climate policy models by allowing for agent heterogeneity, bounded rationality and non-market interactions over social networks. This enables the analysis of a broader spectrum of policies. Here, we review 61 ABM studies addressing climate-energy policy aimed at emissions reduction, product and technology diffusion, and energy conservation. This covers a broad set of instruments of climate policy, ranging from carbon taxation and emissions trading through adoption subsidies to information provision tools such as smart meters and eco-labels. Our treatment pays specific attention to behavioural assumptions and the structure of social networks. We offer suggestions for future research with ABMs to answer neglected policy questions.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A multi-level climate club with national and sub-national members, Theory and application to US states

  • Martin, Nick|||0000-0001-9023-9696
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
The minilateral approach of a climate club of countries has been suggested as an intermediate phase in a transition towards a global agreement that enforces national climate policies through harmonization. To garner critical mass, we propose an extended club configuration including sub-national states or provinces, resulting in a multi-level club. This would allow considerable contributions from important emitters like the US to be brought on board, relevant given its intended withdrawal from the Paris Agreement. We elaborate this idea and clarify potential roles of participants at distinct levels. The concept is operationalized by developing a method for identifying suitable entities at each level that uses a set of likelihood-of-involvement indicators capturing existing carbon dependence, public opinion, government policy and climate coalition membership. Application at the national level identifies a subset of seven of the highest emitting countries representing 21% of global emissions. This rises to 51% assuming that China, the dominant global emitter, could be enticed into the group. Given that US involvement remains unlikely for now, we illustrate selection at the sub-national level for US states. Here, an initial group of 21 states appear as potential members, jointly accounting for 36% of national emissions. An additional group, representing a further 34% of emissions, are potentially receptive to enticement via trade dependencies on four key countries identified within the group of national members. Accordingly, some 70% of US emissions, representing 11% of global totals, may be subject to climate club involvement via a combination of these pathways. While the implementation of such a club requires various political and legal hurdles to be overcome, the ongoing threat of climate change and inadequacies of the Paris Agreement suggest that novel solutions of this kind deserve serious attention from scientists and politicians.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Normalisation of Paris agreement NDCs to enhance transparency and ambition

  • King, Lewis Carl|||0000-0001-6757-2503
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
The Paris Agreement takes a bottom-up approach to tackling climate change with parties submitting pledges in the form of nationally determined contributions (NDCs). Studies show that the sum of these national pledges falls short of meeting the agreement's 2 °C target. To explore this discrepancy, we analyse individual pledges and classify them into four categories. By doing so, a lack of consistency and transparency is highlighted, which we correct for by performing a normalisation that makes pledges directly comparable. This involves calculating changes in emissions by 2030, using data for the most recent base year of 2015. We find that pledges framed in terms of absolute emission reductions against historical base years generally produce the greatest ambition, with average emission reductions of 16% by 2030. Pledges defined as GDP intensity targets perform the worst with average emission increases of 61% by 2030. We propose that a normalisation procedure of the type as we develop becomes part of the NDC process. It will allow to not only increase the transparency of pledges for policymakers and wider society, but also promote more effective NDCs upon revision as is foreseen to happen every 5 years under the 'ratcheting mechanism' of the agreement.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The social multiplier of environmental policy, application to carbon taxation

  • Konc, Théo Aloïs Dimitri|||0000-0002-0203-9473
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
We analyze the effectiveness of environmental policy when consumers are subject to social influence. To this end, we build a model of consumption decisions driven by socially- embedded preferences formed under the influence of peers in a social network. This setting gives rise to a social multiplier of environmental policy. In an application to climate change, we derive Pigouvian and target-achieving carbon taxes under socially-embedded preferences. Under realistic assumptions the social multiplier is equal to 1.30, allowing to reduce the effective tax by 38%. We show that the multiplier depends on four factors: strength of social influence, initial taste distribution, network topology and income distribution. The approach provides a basis for rigorously analyzing a transition to low-carbon lifestyles and identifying complementary information and network policies to maximize the effectiveness of carbon taxation.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A dual-track transition to global carbon pricing

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Angelsen, Arild|||0000-0002-6037-6849
  • Baranzini, Andrea
  • Botzen, W. J. Wouter|||0000-0002-8563-4963
  • Carattini, Stefano
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Dunlop, Tessa|||0000-0002-2265-9880
  • Galbraith, Eric D.|||0000-0003-4476-4232
  • Gsottbauer, Elisabeth
  • Howarth, Richard B.
  • Padilla, Emilio|||0000-0002-9510-8262
  • Roca Jusmet, Jordi|||0000-0001-7766-3759
  • Schmidt, Robert C.
Unilateral climate policies have been unable to achieve intended emissions reductions. We argue that international harmonization of climate policy beyond the Paris Agreement is the only way forward and that global carbon pricing, either through a tax or market, is the best available instrument to manage this. A foundation has already been laid, as current carbon pricing initiatives cover about 20% of global CO2 emissions. Since it limits free-riding by countries/jurisdictions, global carbon pricing is, in principle, behaviourally easier to negotiate than other instruments, such as emission targets or technical standards. To overcome political resistance, we propose a dynamic strategy consisting of two parallel tracks and five transition phases. The first track entails assembly of a carbon-pricing coalition that expands over time and exerts moral and economic pressure on non-members to join. The second track involves refocusing UN intergovernmental climate change negotiations on carbon pricing, potentially involving initially heterogeneous prices reflecting distinct income levels of countries, which then gradually converge. The dual tracks are designed to reinforce one another, increasing the likelihood of a successful outcome. The proposal results in a transition trajectory consisting of two interactive tracks and five phases, with specific attention to inequity within and among countries. We illustrate how such an approach could function with either a carbon tax or market.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A dual-track transition to global carbon pricing, the glass is half full

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Angelsen, Arild|||0000-0002-6037-6849
  • Baranzini, Andrea
  • Botzen, W. J. Wouter|||0000-0002-8563-4963
  • Carattini, Stefano
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Dunlop, Tessa|||0000-0002-2265-9880
  • Galbraith, Eric D.|||0000-0003-4476-4232
  • Gsottbauer, Elisabeth
  • Howarth, Richard B.
  • Padilla, Emilio|||0000-0002-9510-8262
  • Roca Jusmet, Jordi|||0000-0001-7766-3759
  • Schmidt, Robert C.
This article responds to: A dual-track transition to global carbon pricing: nice idea, but doomed to fail (https://doi.org/10.1080/14693062.2020.1816888).
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Free associations of citizens and scientists with economic and green growth, a computational linguistics analysis

  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
The debate about the relationship between economic growth and environmental sustainability triggers a range of associations. Here we analyze open-ended textual responses of citizens and scientists concerning their associations with the terms "economic growth" and "green growth". We derive from the responses a number of topics and examine how associations differ across distinct opinion segments of people, namely supporters of Green growth, Agrowth and Degrowth. The results indicate that the general public is more critical of the notion of economic growth than academic researchers. Citizens stress problems of corruption, social inequality, unemployment and poverty, with less variation among the three opinion segments compared to scientists. The latter more strongly emphasize the environmental consequences of economic growth. Concerning associations of scientists with the term "green growth", we find topics questioning its feasibility to be more likely expressed by Degrowth supporters, while topics stressing the possibility of sustainable economic growth by Green growth supporters. We find that topic polarization is stronger for scientists than citizens. Our results provide further validation for opinion clusters identified in previous studies and uncover additional insights about related views on growth and sustainability.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Public views on carbon taxation and its fairness, a computational-linguistics analysis

  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Maestre Andrés, Sara|||0000-0003-3971-5209
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Carbon taxes evoke a variety of public responses, often with negative implications for policy support, implementation and stringency. Here we use topic modelling to analyze associations of Spanish citizens with a policy proposal to introduce a carbon tax. This involves asking two key questions, to elicit (1) citizens' associations with a carbon tax and (2) their judgment of the fairness of such a policy for distinct uses of tax revenues. We identify 11 topics for the first question and 18 topics for the second. We perform regression analysis to assess how respondents' associations relate to their carbon-tax acceptability, knowledge and socio-demographic characteristics. The results show that, compared to people accepting the carbon tax, those rejecting it show less trust in politicians, think that the rich should pay more than the poor, consider the tax to be less fair, and stress more a lack of renewable energy or low-carbon transport. Respondents accepting a carbon tax emphasize more the need to solve environmental problems and care about a just society. These insights can help policy makers to improve the design and communication of climate policy with the aim to increase its public acceptability.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Low-carbon transition is improbable without carbon pricing

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Botzen, W. J. Wouter|||0000-0002-8563-4963
This Letter has a Reply and related content. Please see: Reply to van den Bergh and Botzen: A clash of paradigms over the role of carbon pricing (https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2014350117) - Opinion: Why carbon pricing is not sufficient to mitigate climate change-and how "sustainability transition policy" can help (https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2004093117).
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Systemic assessment of urban climate policies worldwide, decomposing effectiveness into 3 factors

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Optimism about the contribution of city policies worldwide to reduce greenhouse gas emissions is widespread. It is based, though, on partial and anecdotal studies rather than comprehensive system-wide estimates. Popular empirical indicators to support the importance of cities, such as consumption-based emissions within city borders, lack a policy connection. Here I undertake an initial assessment of the effectiveness of emissions reduction through urban climate policies. It employs a novel decomposition of effectiveness into reach, capability and stringency. This results in a qualitative estimation of current and maximum contributions of city climate policies - divided into four types - to global emissions reduction. I formalize the framework to numerically illustrate additional policy aspects. Based on the insights obtained, I suggest policy and political strategies to make better use of cities' competences to mitigate climate change.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Assessing synergy of incentives and nudges in the energy policy mix

  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Exadaktylos, Filippos|||0000-0001-7339-8847
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Should policy-makers combine price incentives with behavioural nudges to encourage sustainable energy behaviour? Available evidence from various behavioural sciences is scarce and inconclusive about synergy of the two instruments. This is partly due to methodological limitations. We offer a framework to overcome such limitations in future research and to guide policy-making. It includes four cases: no synergy, positive synergy, weak negative synergy, and strong negative synergy or backfire. The adoption of a policy mix is recommended in the first two cases, and may be pursued in the third case. To clarify the underlying mechanisms of the synergy, a distinction is made between crowding (in/out) of intrinsic motivations by incentives and crowding (in/out) of extrinsic motivations by nudges. This distinction turns out to be especially relevant in the case of weakly negative synergy, as here behavioural and temporal spillover effects require consideration from the policy-maker as well. We end with broader reflections regarding other policy criteria for the design of an adequate energy policy mix.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The employment double dividend of environmental tax reforms, exploring the role of agent behaviour and social interaction

  • Klein, Franziska|||0000-0001-6968-6213
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
It has been long debated whether environmental tax reform (ETR), i.e. a revenue-neutral shift of the tax burden from labour to carbon emissions, can have a double dividend, in terms of climate and economic goals. So far this question has been addressed in public finance and environmental economics using models with rational and representative agents. Here we examine the relevance of deviating from these standard behavioural assumptions. Our motivation is that research from other fields indicates that impacts of both environmental and income taxation on households are sensitive to behavioural biases, such as habits, imitation or status seeking. A related feature is that consumers and firms are heterogeneous with respect to many characteristics, some of which are crucial for the distributional effects of a tax reform. We combine insights from social psychology and behavioural, evolutionary and labour economics to identify behavioural cases in which the impacts of an ETR is likely to differ significantly from those in the traditional framework. Our findings show that households' time use patterns and the distinction between extensive and intensive labour supply are relevant and deserve more attention.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Emission tax vs. permit trading under bounded rationality and dynamic markets

  • Foramitti, Joël|||0000-0002-4828-7288
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
A price on emissions can be achieved through an emission tax or permit trading. The advan- tages and drawbacks of either instrument are debated. We present an agent-based model to compare their performance under bounded rationality and dynamic markets. It describes firms that face uncertainty about future demand and prices; use heuristic rules to decide production levels, trading prices, and technology adoption; and are heterogeneous in terms of production factors, abatement costs, and trading behavior. Using multiple evaluation criteria and a wide range of parameter values, we find that the main difference between the two policies lies in the fact that permit prices fall after successful abatement. This can lead to higher production levels under permit trading, but can also drive emission-efficient firms out of the market. Scarcity rents under permit trading can further create higher profit rates for firms, the extent of which is shown to depend on the mechanisms for market-clearing and initial allocation.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The virtues of virtual conferences

  • Foramitti, Joël|||0000-0002-4828-7288
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Klein, Franziska|||0000-0001-6968-6213
  • Konc, Théo|||0000-0002-0203-9473
In this comment, we share our experiences from organizing the ICTA2020 Virtual Conference on Low-Carbon Lifestyles and argue that virtual events have potential to become the new norm among academics. We present an overview of tools that can be used and support our arguments with results from a feedback survey that was filled out by the participants of our conference. Main challenges for virtual conferences are the facilitation of informal spaces for social interaction and the prevention of 'screen fatigue'. Advantages are that they can increase societal outreach, improve the academic quality of discussions, create new opportunities for networking, and provide an inclusive environment.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

An evolutionary approach to passive learning in optimal control problems

  • Blueschke, D.
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Blueschke-Nikolaeva, V.
We consider the optimal control problem of a small nonlinear econometric model under parameter uncertainty and passive learning (open-loop feedback). Traditionally, this type of problems has been approached by applying linear-quadratic optimization algorithms. However, the literature demonstrated that those methods are very sensitive to the choice of random seeds frequently producing very large objective function values (outliers). Furthermore, to apply those established methods, the original nonlinear problem must be linearized first, which runs the risk of solving already a different problem. Following Savin and Blueschke (Comput Econ 48(2):317-338, 2016) in explicitly addressing parameter uncertainty with a large Monte Carlo experiment of possible parameter realizations and optimizing it with the Differential Evolution algorithm, we extend this approach to the case of passive learning. Our approach provides more robust results demonstrating greater benefit from learning, while at the same time does not require to modify the original nonlinear problem at hand. This result opens new avenues for application of heuristic optimization methods to learning strategies in optimal control research.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Designing an effective climate-policy mix, accounting for instrument synergy

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Castro Santa, Juana|||0000-0002-6411-9460
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Exadaktylos, Filippos|||0000-0001-7339-8847
  • Foramitti, Joël|||0000-0002-4828-7288
  • Klein, Franziska|||0000-0001-6968-6213
  • Konc, Théo Aloïs Dimitri|||0000-0002-0203-9473
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
We assess evidence from theoretical-modelling, empirical and experimental studies on how interactions between instruments of climate policy affect overall emissions reduction. Such interactions take the form of negative, zero or positive synergistic effects. The considered instruments comprise performance and technical standards, carbon pricing, adoption subsidies, innovation support, and information provision. Based on the findings, we formulate climate-policy packages that avoid negative and employ positive synergies, and compare their strengths and weaknesses on other criteria. We note that the international context of climate policy has been neglected in assessments of policy mixes, and argue that transparency and harmonization of national policies may be key to a politically feasible path to meet global emission targets. This suggests limiting the complexity of climate-policy packages.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

How work patterns affect leisure activities and energy consumption, A time-use analysis for Finland and France

  • Klein, Franziska|||0000-0001-6968-6213
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Studies on socio-economic impacts of climate and energy policies tend to focus on income and expenditure effects. For analyses that go beyond monetary dimensions, time-diary data have proven to be useful. Here we investigate how work time relates to leisure activity structures and associated energy use for different types of employees. To this end, an analysis of time-use data is undertaken for Finland and France. Novel elements are (1) a differentiation between part-time and full-time employees, (2) the use of distinct energy intensities of different activities by household type instead of average energy intensities, and (3) allowing for non-linear relationships between work time and the allocation of other activities. Our results suggest that the effects of work time on energy use are rather homogeneous in Finland, whereas we find more differences between employee types in France. In both countries, adjustment of leisure-activity duration is sometimes strong initially but flattening for longer work hours. This relates to another finding, namely that the composition of leisure activities differs between people with distinct work hours. Our study suggests that analysis of disaggregated time-use data can add relevant insights for evaluation, and possibly design, of energy, climate and labour-market policies.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Potential carbon leakage under the Paris agreement

  • King, Lewis Carl|||0000-0001-6757-2503
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Carbon leakage is the effect of emissions transferring to certain countries due to others having a stricter climate policy. This phenomenon is shown to have undercut the effectiveness of the Kyoto Protocol. Considering the increasingly globalised nature of the world economy, carbon leakage may have an even greater potential under the Paris Agreement some fifteen years later. Although a more global approach to combatting climate change, the Paris Agreement is susceptible to leakage because of its lack of policy harmonization and enforcement mechanisms. Here we perform the first quantitative analysis of the potential for carbon leakage under Paris, using the GTAP-E general equilibrium model of the world economy with energy and carbon emissions to analyse leakage effects under six scenarios. Two of these scenarios analyse regions implementing climate policy in isolation, two greater participation, but still not harmonized, global Paris Agreement policy, and a further two analyse the effect of a US withdrawal from the agreement. Both cases are considered with and without the US withdrawal. Our analysis demonstrates that there is potential for significant carbon leakage effects, in line with the rates produced from studies on the Kyoto Protocol. Depending on model elasticities, we find medium carbon leakage in the range of 1-9% (with a central estimate of 3-4%) under co-ordinated Paris Agreement policy across countries, compared to high leakage of 8-31% when countries operate in isolation. However, scenarios where the US withdraws from the agreement result in roughly doubling of leakage rates, in the range of 3-16% (central estimate 7%), which demonstrates the vulnerability of the Paris Agreement in its current form. To limit leakage effects greater policy co-ordination to achieve consistent implicit carbon prices is needed across countries.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

GEM, A short "Growth-vs-Environment" Module for survey research

  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Segmentation of survey respondents is a common tool in environmental communication as it helps to understand opinions of people and to deliver targeted messages. Prior research has segmented people based on their opinions about the relationship between economic growth and environmental sustainability. This involved an evaluation of 16 statements, which means considerable survey time and cost, particularly if administered by a third party, as well as cognitive burden on respondents, increasing the chance of incomplete responses. In this study, we apply a machine learning algorithm to results from past surveys among citizens and scientists to identify a robust, minimal set of questions that accurately segments respondents regarding their opinion on growth versus the environment. In particular, we distinguish three groups, called Green growth, Agrowth and Degrowth. To this end, we identify five perceptions, namely regarding 'environmental protection', 'public services', 'life satisfaction', 'stability' and 'development space'. Prediction accuracy ranges between 81% and 89% across surveys and opinion segments. We apply the proposed set of questions on growth-vs-environment to a new survey from 2020 to illustrate its use as an efficient instrument in future surveys.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Impact of Carbon Pricing on Low-Carbon Innovation and Deep Decarbonisation, Controversies and Path Forward

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
There is an ongoing discussion about the effectiveness of carbon pricing, with a strong division between optimists and pessimists. A recent review study by Lilliestam, Patt and Bersalli (2021) of the impact of carbon pricing on low-carbon innovation and deep carbonization concludes that there is no evidence for such an impact. We evaluate this study and identify various shortcomings of it, which together cast strong doubts on its main conclusion. Instead, we conclude, based on the studies reviewed by the authors and additional, overlooked literature, that carbon pricing has had a small but positive and significant effect on low-carbon innovation. Our evaluation provides lessons for undertaking a systematic and objective review of research on this topic. Since the main goal of carbon pricing is changing choices by firms and consumers that affect carbon emissions, we also point the reader towards recent evidence for the broader effectiveness of carbon pricing.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Energy-related behaviour and rebound when rationality, self-interest and willpower are limited

  • Exadaktylos, Filippos|||0000-0001-7339-8847
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
The extent to which adopting energy-efficient technologies results in energy savings depends on how such technologies are used, and how monetary savings from energy efficiency are spent. Energy rebound occurs when potential energy savings are diminished due to post-adoption behaviour. Here we review empirical studies on how six behavioural regularities affect three energy-relevant decisions and ultimately rebound: adoption of energy-saving products or practices, their intensity of use and spending of associated monetary savings. The findings suggest that behaviours that reflect limited rationality and willpower may increase rebound, while the effects of behaviours driven by bounded self-interest are less clear. We then describe how interventions associated with each of the behavioural regularities can influence rebound and thus serve to achieve higher energy savings. Future research ought to study energy-relevant decisions in a more integrated manner, with a particular focus on re-spending as this presents the greatest challenge for research and policy.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Regulation at the source? Comparing upstream and downstream climate policies

  • Foramitti, Joël|||0000-0002-4828-7288
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Climate policies can be applied either upstream, where fossil fuels are extracted, or downstream, where emissions are generated. Specific policy instruments can be defined for either level, and can take the form of a price signal such as through a tax, or a quantity limit such as through direct regulation or a permit market. In this study, we present an agent-based model to compare the performance of these different instruments and regulation levels. Since policy coverage is often limited, i.e. not all firms being under the regulator's control, we also examine the impact of incomplete coverage on relative policy performance. Our analysis shows that only upstream regulation leads to an increase in fossil fuel prices, which is benefitial under limited coverage as it also affects firms not directly affected by the policy instruments; that prices under quantity-based regulation can decline after an initial peak, stabilizing at a lower level than under the tax; and that direct regulation is more efficient when applied upstream.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Assessing the authenticity of national carbon prices, A comparison of 31 countries

  • Finch, Adam
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Many countries have carbon pricing in place, in the form of a tax and/or market. Generally, this involves low price rates, incomplete emissions coverage, and price reductions for particular sectors. This raises the question whether the label "carbon price" - in the environmental-economics textbook sense - really applies. To answer it, we assess the authenticity of 31 national carbon prices, calculating average carbon prices and their gap with advertised prices, at both national and sector levels. The results indicate a poor level of authenticity. This means that the carbon prices published by sources such as the World Bank provide a misleading representation of the actual national policy pressure on emissions. Countries show considerable differences regarding the average carbon price level and the gap with advertised prices. Moreover, there is not a one-to-one relationship between advertised and average carbon prices, suggesting the former are not a good basis for international comparison of policy effectiveness. Across countries, the mean carbon price equals €7.90/ton of CO while the mean price gap is 57.7%. Most noticeably, the highest advertised price for Sweden should be interpreted with care as it goes along with a price gap of almost €100 to the average price. In addition, Switzerland and Finland show relatively high price gaps. To illustrate the relevance and non-triviality of our indicators, note that Sweden occupies a 3rd position in terms of average carbon price (after Norway and Switzerland), 27th in terms of price gap, and 16th in terms of effective rate (i.e. sum of implicit and explicit carbon prices). We further find that implicit carbon prices dominate explicit ones for most countries, notably in road transport, whereas the reverse holds for industrial and electricity sectors. Combining our findings with recent empirical evidence for carbon-pricing effectiveness highlights the potential of the instrument to combat climate change, provided implementation is improved and internationally harmonized. Shifting the attention from advertised to average carbon prices might help in this regard.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Biased perceptions of other people's attitudes to carbon taxation

  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Beliefs about other people's opinions on climate change influence one's own opinion. Such beliefs can, however, suffer from biases in perception. Using two nationally representative surveys, we examine this issue in a new context, namely of carbon-tax acceptance in Spain. We find that the more one expects the tax to be accepted by others, the more one accepts it personally. But opponents of a carbon tax tend to strongly overestimate the prevalence of their opinion, i.e. they exhibit a so-called false consensus effect. In contrast, despite holding the majority view, tax supporters somewhat underestimate the prevalence of their own view, which is known as pluralistic ignorance. We further test the role of information provision by providing participants with different percentages of people accepting the tax. Overall, we find little evidence that such information provision significantly increases tax acceptance. The impact of information provision on tax acceptance tends to be moderated by the degree of false consensus.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Co-dynamics of climate policy stringency and public support

  • Konc, Théo Aloïs Dimitri|||0000-0002-0203-9473
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Public support for stringent climate policies is currently weak. We develop a model to study the dynamics of public support for climate policies. It comprises three interconnected modules: one calculates policy impacts; a second translates these into policy support mediated by social influence; and a third represents the regulator adapting policy stringency depending on public support. The model combines general-equilibrium and agent-based elements and is empirically grounded in a household survey, which allows quantifying policy support as a function of effectiveness, personal wellbeing and distributional effects. We apply our approach to compare two policy instruments, namely carbon taxation and performance standards, and identify intertemporal trajectories that meet the climate target and count on sufficient public support. Our results highlight the importance of social influence, opinion stability and income inequality for public support of climate policies. Our model predicts that carbon taxation consistently generates more public support than standards. Finally, we show that under moderate social influence and income inequality, an increasing carbon tax trajectory combined with progressive revenue redistribution receives the highest average public support over time.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Climate concern and policy acceptance before and after COVID-19

  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Villamayor-Tomas, Sergio|||0000-0002-5170-1718
It remains unclear how COVID-19 has affected public engagement with the climate crisis. According to the finite-pool-of-worry hypothesis, concern about climate change should have decreased after the pandemic, in turn reducing climate-policy acceptance. Here we test these and several other conjectures by using survey data from 1172 Spanish participants who responded before and after the first wave of COVID-19, allowing for both aggregate and within-person analyses. We find that on average climate concern has decreased, while acceptance of most climate policies has increased. At the individual-level, adverse health experiences are unrelated to these changes. The same holds for negative economic experiences, with the exception that unemployment is associated with reduced acceptance of some policies. Complementary to the finite-pool-of-worry test, we examine three additional pandemic-related issues. As we find, (1) higher climate concern and policy acceptance are associated with a belief that climate change contributed to the COVID-19 outbreak; (2) higher policy acceptance is associated with a positive opinion about how the government addressed the COVID-19 crisis; (3) citizens show favorable attitudes to a carbon tax with revenues used to compensate COVID-19-related expenditures. Overall, we conclude there is support for addressing the global climate crisis even during a global health crisis.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

ABM-IAM, optimal climate policy under bounded rationality and multiple inequalities

  • Safarzyńska, Karolina
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Despite considerable concern about potentially inequitable effects of climate policy, models fall short in assessing their implications for policy design. To address this issue, we develop an agent-based climate-economy model, agent-based modelling-Integrated Assessment Model, as a disaggregated, behavioural approach to integrated climate assessment. It describes networks of heterogeneous consumers, banks, power plants and firms, and is calibrated on patterns of growth and carbon dioxide emissions generated by the DICE model of Nordhaus. Whereas the latter assumes full employment and abstains from a financial sector and inequality considerations, our approach relaxes these restrictions to obtain a more reliable assessment of climate policy impacts. We show that inequalities in labour and capital income serve as essential but overlooked links between climate-change damages and optimal climate policy. Our result show that lower inequalities of labour income increase the social cost of carbon (SCC), while the impact of capital income inequalities on the SCC depends on the share of population receiving capital rents.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Tired of climate targets? Shift focus of IPCC scenarios from emission and growth targets to policies

  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Climate change has revived the debate on growth-versus-environment. In line with this, recently it has been proposed to shift the target focus of IPCC scenarios from emissions to post-growth. We argue here that this confounds ends and means, since while reduction of growth may be an outcome of good climate policies, it should not be a goal in itself. In fact, a post- or degrowth goal would mean an ineffective and costly way to reduce emissions. Instead, we suggest that the debate about pursuing economic growth versus achieving climate goals will become more transparent and policy-relevant through refocusing scenarios from targets to policy.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A framework for agent-based models of human needs and ecological limits

  • Foramitti, Joël|||0000-0002-4828-7288
The social and ecological challenges of our time require a better understanding of the complex interactions between the multiple dimensions of human well-being and environmental impacts. This article introduces the Needs and Limits (N&L) framework, a theoretical and computational foundation for agent-based simulations of heterogeneous individuals who try to increase their quality of life through the satisfaction of human needs. Based on psychological research, human needs are described as satiable, adaptive, and interdependent with the social and bio-physical environment. The N&L framework represents a generic foundation that can be applied to a broad range of socio-economic and ecological scenarios. A comparison is provided with classical utility approaches. The framework is illustrated for the topics of income inequality and climate policy.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Nudging low-carbon consumption through advertising and social norms

  • Castro Santa, Juana|||0000-0002-6411-9460
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Widespread advertising of high-carbon goods challenges a shift to low-carbon consumption which is needed to limit climate change. We test the pure and combined effects of advertising and communicating a social norm on low- and high-carbon consumption. This involved presenting to 2728 US citizens an imitation Facebook homepage containing green and non-green advertising as well as weak and strong social norms to nudge low-carbon consumption. In isolation, both green advertising and social norms were effective in promoting low-carbon choices. But when combined, advertising dominated choice and counteracted the positive effects of the social norm. We show that this result is due to advertising affecting more decision channels than the social norm. It suggests that low-carbon norms have a limited effectiveness in changing consumer preferences in a world dominated by advertising.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Capítulo o parte de un libro (BookPart)

Contribution of Global Cities to Climate Change Mitigation Overrated

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Local solutions to global environment challenges form part of the Martinez-Alier style of ecological economics in Barcelona. This tends to involve an optimistic assessment of the role of cities. Here, I consider this role for the case of urban policies aimed at reducing carbon emissions. There is indeed considerable optimism about the role of cities in global reduction of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. I appraise recent studies and conclude that they (1) do not account for the limited reach of urban policies; (2) overplay voluntary action and underplay the importance of effective regulation; (3) disregard free riding and systemic effects like carbon leakage; and (4) lack quantitative estimates of the overall contribution of cities to emissions reduction, at best providing empirical indicators that do not connect well with urban policies. I provide an initial, tentative estimate of the upper bound to the contribution of city policies worldwide to global emissions reduction as equal to 16.8%, while realistic policies are assessed to control no more than 2%. These numbers underpin that the major part of emissions generated within city borders is outside the control of local policies, instead depending on policies set by national governments.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo de revisión (ReviewArticle)

Heuristic processing of green advertising, Review and policy implications : Review and policy implications

  • Castro Santa, Juana|||0000-0002-6411-9460
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
Green advertising aims to communicate pro-environmental dimensions of products to achieve an increase in sales. Within a general advertising framework, we organize studies of green advertising to examine the psychological processes it triggers and how it influences consumers. We analyze (1) the information typically conveyed in green advertising through verbal and non-verbal cues, (2) the moderating variables of consumers' attention, and (3) the cognitive and emotional responses to green advertising. We describe the latter through the prism of heuristics, i.e. simple rules of thumb that consumers use to analyze cues. We find that five main heuristics drive consumer responses to green advertising. We discuss how these heuristics can create psychological barriers for required changes in consumption to reduce emissions, and what policies can overcome adverse, and promote beneficial effects of green advertising.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Capítulo o parte de un libro (BookPart)

The role of carbon pricing in energy-transitions research and policy

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Botzen, W. J. Wouter|||0000-0002-8563-4963
This chapter examines the relevance of carbon pricing for transition policy. It argues that carbon pricing should be a key element of a broader transition policy as it triggers multiple processes that critically matter to a low-carbon transition. Since carbon pricing has been criticized by various researchers in transition studies, their concerns and arguments are evaluated here. The chapter further draw attention to the international dimension of a transition to a low-carbon economy, given that climate policy is a global public good and thus amenable to free riding by countries. In addition, it clarifies the need for a policy instrument that avoids counter-productive systemic effects, such as carbon leakage and energy rebound. It is explained that carbon pricing performs relatively well in both respects. In addition, the role of carbon pricing as part of a wider policy package is examined, accounting for positive and negative synergies between instruments. The chapter ends with proposing that transition studies pay closer attention to carbon pricing, providing various recommendations for research.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Capítulo o parte de un libro (BookPart)

A critical assessment of the effectiveness of low-carbon nudges

  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
There is hope that nudges are a useful and effective complement to more traditional instruments of climate and environmental policy. This chapter provides a comprehensive, systemic assessment of the potential of low-carbon nudges. It starts by synthesizing recent evidence from reviews and meta-analyses on the effectiveness of stand-alone nudges. Various sources indicate that overall emission-reduction effects tend to be modest. We discuss reasons for why nudges sometimes fail, such as habits, rebound and counter-nudges. Next, we examine how nudges interact with other policies, and what this implies for policy effectiveness and acceptance. The chapter ends with a broader discussion of the role of behavioral science and nudges in the context of a low-carbon transition.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Sugar taxation for climate and sustainability goals

  • King, Lewis Carl|||0000-0001-6757-2503
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Meeting environmental sustainability goals while simultaneously recovering from the health and economic crises arising from the coronavirus pandemic requires creative policy solutions. Sugar taxation presents one such policy as sugar crops are arguably the least efficient to consume from a health perspective, but the most efficient for biofuel production. Here, we analyse the sustainability co-benefits of reducing sugar consumption through redirecting existing sugar cropland to alternative uses. Emissions could fall 20.9-54.3 MtCO2e yr-1, if the EU were to reduce its sugar consumption in line with health guidelines and the excess Brazilian sugarcane redirected to ethanol. These savings would be around four times higher than an alternative strategy of afforesting existing EU sugar beet cropland and double those from producing sugar beet ethanol in the EU. Achieving this through policies aimed at behavioural change, with a serious role for sugar taxation, would not only reduce the environmental impacts of biofuels but also provide health and economic benefits.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Evolution and recombination of topics in Technological Forecasting and Social Change

  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
Technological Forecasting and Social Change (TFSC) is one of the main outlets in the literature on technological change. To assist its editors and future contributors in understanding the evolution of the journal, we review studies published between 1970 and 2022 identifying 25 main themes ranging from scenario foresight and forecasting methods that dominated the journal agenda in the first decades through innovation diffusion and patent analysis that gained popularity in 2006-2019 to social interaction and financial markets which experienced momentum in the last couple of years. We find that studies concentrated on more recent topics like firm performance, financial markets and environmental regulation have been cited more frequently and were contributed more often by scientists from China compared to the US. Inspired by the fact that studies recombining two or more topics are more impactful in terms of citations, we construct a graph of topics, both for the overall sample of 6240 studies reviewed and three periods of TFSC existence corresponding to different editors-in-chief. Our results illustrate knowledge complementarities explored in the journal so far and may indicate directions for further research.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

How carbon pricing affects multiple human needs, an agent-based model analysis

  • Foramitti, Joël|||0000-0002-4828-7288
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Climate policy is urgently needed to reduce emissions, but must also be evaluated in regard to its impact on human quality of life. To identify policy approaches that are able to achieve effective mitigation together with high levels of well-being, multiple human needs must be taken into account. To this end, we present an agent-based model that is able to describe the interaction between various economic sectors on the supply-side and individuals with heterogeneous incomes and needs on the demand-side. Individuals make choices under both income and time constraints; the latter being needed for non-market activities and time-intensive forms of consumption such as low-carbon modes of transport. The following climate policy instruments are considered: a carbon tax, permit trading, direct regulation, and investments in low-carbon infrastructure. Impacts are analyzed in regard to three different types of mitigation: avoid, shift, and improve. Results show that to achieve emission reductions together with high levels of well-being, carbon pricing is best combined with effective improvements of low-carbon infrastructure; revenue recycling should be progressive; and unnecessary abatement costs should be avoided. A comparison is provided with traditional formulations of social welfare.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

A Global Survey of Scientific Consensus and Controversy on Instruments of Climate Policy

  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
There is continuing debate about which climate-policy instruments are most appropriate to reduce emissions. Undertaking a global survey among scientists who published on climate policy, we provide a systematic overview of (dis)agreements about six main types of policy instruments. The survey includes various fields across the social and natural sciences. The results show that, on average, all instruments are considered important, with direct regulation receiving the highest rating and adoption subsidies and cap-and-trade the lowest. The latter is surprising given the theoretical advantages and real-world success of the EU-ETS. Next, clustering scientific fields based on how important they consider the instruments, we determine five distinct groups, with (a) ecological economists and (b) mathematics/computer science being most dissimilar from other discipline clusters. We explain disagreement through assessing the relative importance assigned to policy criteria effectiveness, efficiency, equity and socio-political feasibility, as well as researchers' attitudes and background. Paying special attention to carbon pricing, motivated by its contested key role, we identify three respondent clusters, namely 'enthusiasts', 'undecided', and 'skeptics'. Examining various policy arguments, we find that agreeing that carbon pricing effectively limits energy/carbon rebound and has potential to be harmonized globally have the strongest association with giving importance to this policy.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Carbon pricing - perceived strengths, weaknesses and knowledge gaps according to a global expert survey

  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Researchers from different disciplines have different opinions about carbon pricing. To better understand the reasoning behind these perspectives, we utilize responses to three open-ended questions from a global survey among almost 800 researchers from a wide variety of fields who published on climate policy. Using methods from computational linguistics, we classify reflections of researchers on the main strengths and weaknesses of carbon pricing compared with other policy instruments in seven and six topics, respectively. The results indicate that the main perceived strengths of carbon pricing are that it is effective and efficient at reducing emissions, gives clear investment incentives, decentralizes policy, among others. The main perceived weaknesses of carbon pricing are related to its potentially regressive effects on households, low social-political support, and amenability to manipulation-to name a few. Surprisingly, not all these perceptions are in line with established theory and empirical evidence. Finally, we collect suggestions for future research. Among nine frequently mentioned themes are improving public understanding of carbon pricing, political acceptability, synergies with other policies, long-term effects, and implementation in an equitable way in developing countries and worldwide. In addition, we highlight several less frequent but arguably innovative research avenues. Finally, we report to what extent the identified topics on strengths, weaknesses and knowledge gaps are significantly related to academic experience, gender, GDP per capita in the countries of origin and residence of the survey participants, and perceived importance of carbon pricing. This information helps identifying key differences in views within the scientific community on carbon pricing and can guide communication between fields aimed at reaching more consensus on climate policy.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Testing mechanisms through which China's ETS promotes a low-carbon transition

  • Liu, Feng|||0000-0003-3383-7598
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Wei, Yihang
China regards an emission trading scheme (ETS) as the most promising approach for reducing its carbon dioxide emissions. However, there are still disagreements about the effectiveness of China's ETS (CETS). To settle this issue, we test the impact of CETS on key mechanisms driving a low-carbon transition. We use the difference-in-difference method to analyze data for coal-power plants participating in China's carbon trading pilot. This involves the use of two variables based on life-cycle indicators, namely 'energy return on energy invested' (EROI) and 'energy return on carbon invested' (EROC). We obtain three main findings: (1) a mediating effect of supply-side reform is significant; (2) this effect is stronger for more intense technological innovation and government intervention; (3) the influence of CETS on a low-carbon transition is independent of the development of clean energy. Overall, we conclude that the scope of CETS should be extended to other emitters to fully unleash its potential for reducing carbon emissions.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Behavioral spillovers from green purchases, comparing impacts on consumption and policy support

  • Castro Santa, Juana|||0000-0002-6411-9460
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Green labels and green advertising aim to promote products associated with less energy demands and lower carbon emissions. However, there are indications that purchasing green products may trigger negative spillover effects to subsequent pro-environmental behaviors. One policy-relevant question is whether spillovers from green purchases vary between different types of pro-environmental behaviors, notably consumption vs. policy support, and what determines any differences. Another important question is whether the price of green products affects the magnitude and direction of such spillover effects. Using an experiment among US citizens (N = 1,985), we show that spillovers from green purchases differ significantly between pro-environmental behaviors. In particular we find that spillovers are positive for green consumption and negative for climate policy support. Regarding price effects, we do not find robust evidence on their moderating role but only a tendency for cheap prices to exacerbate the direction of the spillover: negative for policy support and positive for green consumption. Finally, pro-environmental identity, previously suggested in the literature as a central moderator of spillover effects from green purchases, appears to be less determinant.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Assessing criticisms of carbon pricing

  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Botzen, W. J. Wouter|||0000-0002-8563-4963
There is still considerable resistance against carbon pricing - i.e. carbon taxation or cap-and-trade - in the social and policy sciences. We review its main arguments and conclude that they are not supported by the theoretical and empirical literature on instrument performance. Critics are also unable to offer alternative and feasible instruments that limit free riding in climate solutions and perform better on main evaluation criteria, namely effectiveness, efficiency, equity, and global-harmonization potential. Their argument that carbon pricing meets strong political resistance is countered by its widespread implementation already and by its ability to compensate inequitable impacts. We argue that overcoming unsubstantiated criticism on carbon pricing will lead to more consistent advice from policy experts to politicians, thus improving the feasibility of, and accelerating progress towards, globally harmonized and stringent climate policy. All in all, it might be more widely acknowledged that the remarkable feature of carbon pricing is that, if well implemented, it has a great number of advantages and few disadvantages. Rather than weakening political support by criticizing carbon pricing, critics would contribute more productively to effective global climate policy by defending proper and uniform implementation of it.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Public expectations about the impact of COVID-19 on climate action by citizens and government

  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Drews, Stefan|||0000-0001-6393-3121
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
  • Villamayor-Tomas, Sergio|||0000-0002-5170-1718
Since the onset of the COVID-19 crisis many have opinionated on how it may affect society's response to climate change. Two key questions here are how COVID-19 is expected to influence climate action by citizens and by the government. We answer these by applying topic modelling to textual responses from a survey of Spanish citizens. The identified topics tend to be more negative than positive, and more optimistic concerning future climate action by citizens. Positive views involve increasing pro-environmental behavior and are more common among younger, higher educated and male respondents as well as among those who perceive climate change as a serious threat or positively assessed COVID-19 confinement. Negative topics express concern that financial resources for climate action will be limited due to a focus on healthcare and economic recovery. In addition, they mention government mismanagement and waste due to use of protective measures like masks and gloves as impediments to effective climate action.
Dipòsit Digital de Documents de la UAB
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Agent-based modeling to integrate elements from different disciplines for ambitious climate policy

  • Savin, Ivan|||0000-0002-9469-0510
  • Creutzig, Felix|||0000-0002-5710-3348
  • Filatova, Tatiana|||0000-0002-3546-6930
  • Foramitti, Joël|||0000-0002-4828-7288
  • Konc, Théo Aloïs Dimitri|||0000-0002-0203-9473
  • Niamir, Leila|||0000-0002-0285-5542
  • Safarzynska, Karolina|||0000-0001-8924-2038
  • Van den Bergh, Jeroen|||0000-0003-3415-3083
Ambitious climate mitigation policies face social and political resistance. One reason is that existing policies insufficiently capture the diversity of relevant insights from the social sciences about potential policy outcomes. We argue that agent-based models can serve as a powerful tool for integration of elements from different disciplines. Having such a common platform will enable a more complete assessment of climate policies, in terms of criteria like effectiveness, equity and public support. This article is categorized under: Climate Models and Modeling.