Repositorio Digital de la UPF
Publicación
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
Ranking for engagement: how social media algorithms fuel misinformation and polarization
Social media are at the center of countless debates on polarization, misinformation, and even the state of democracy in various parts of the world. An essential feature of social media is their recommendation algorithm that determines the ranking of content presented to the users. This paper investigates the dynamic feedback loop between recommendation algorithms and user behavior, and develops a theoretical framework to assess the impact of popularity-based parameters on platform engagement, misinformation, and polarization. The model uncovers a fundamental trade-off: assigning greater weight to online social interactions—such as likes and shares—increases user engagement but also increases misinformation (crowding-out the truth) and polarization. Building on this insight, the analysis considers how a simple “engagement tax” on social interactions can mitigate these negative externalities by altering platform incentives in the design of profit-maximizing algorithms. The framework is extended to include personalized rankings, demonstrating that personalization further amplifies polarization. Finally, empirical evidence from survey data in Italy and the United States indicates that Facebook’s 2018 “Meaningful Social Interactions” update—which increased the emphasis on certain engagement metrics—contributed to increased ideological extremism and affective polarization., A previous version of the paper circulated with title “Crowding out the truth? A simple model of misinformation, polarization, and meaningful social interactions” (October 2022). We are very grateful to the editor, Erik Snowberg, and two anonymous referees for insightful suggestions. We thank Roland Bénabou, Filipe Campante, Lorenzo Cappello, Alexander Frug, Gaël Le Mens, and audiences at the 2022 AI+Economics Workshop (ETH Zurich), the 8th International Conference on Computational Social Science in Chicago (IC2S2 2022), the 5th Economics of Media Bias Workshop (Berlin 2022), the 50th EARIE Annual Conference in Rome, the European Economic Association and Econometric Society European Meeting in Barcelona (EEA-ESEM 2023), the Interdisciplinary Conference “The Future of Democracy?” (WZB Berlin 2025), and at the Jornadas de Economía Industrial in Santander (JEI 2025), for helpful comments. Germano acknowledges financial support from Grant MICIU/AEI/UE-PID2023-153318NB-I00 and from the Severo Ochoa Programme for Centres of Excellence in R&D (Barcelona School of Economics CEX2024-001476-S), funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033. Sobbrio is grateful to Nando Pagnoncelli and IPSOS for providing access to the Polimetro data. Cristiano Passeri provided excellent research assistance.
Proyecto:
ES / 3PE PID2023-153318NB-I00