DIGITAL.CSIC. Repositorio Institucional del CSIC
Publicación
Artículo científico (JournalArticle)
Comparative assessment of automated and manual monitoring in comprehensive plant–pollinator communities
Pollinator declines pose a significant threat to ecosystem services, making effective monitoring methods critical for conservation efforts. Current research on pollination interactions remains constrained by traditional methods such as direct observations, which have limited spatial and temporal coverage and are inherently biased toward diurnal interactions. Moreover, the presence of human observers can alter pollinator behaviour, and field notebooks serve as the only permanent records, restricting data accessibility and reproducibility.
To overcome these challenges, we developed an Automated Camera System (ACS) that integrates Raspberry Pi hardware with YOLOv5, a deep learning-based object detection model, to detect pollinators in plant communities. The system was trained on video recordings of plant–pollinator interactions collected over 4 years across four different islands. Detected pollinators were subsequently classified to the species level by an entomologist, who also determined which individuals had landed on floral structures. We also conducted 13 field campaigns across six study sites over two spring seasons to monitor all flowering plants using both direct observations and multiple ACS units. This approach allowed us to compare the plant–pollinator data acquired by each method.
The resulting datasets derived from ACS and direct observations shared similar characteristics (e.g. species richness and Shannon diversity) and core interactions. However, ACS recorded higher pollinator visitation rates per individual and species than direct observations, likely due to the absence of human observers. Additionally, ACS detected a greater proportion of interactions, particularly low-frequency ones, which significantly influenced network metrics and lead to higher connectance and specialisation and lower robustness. Despite these advantages, ACS had difficulties in detecting small-bodied pollinators (<5 mm), highlighting an area for future refinement.
This is the first study to introduce an open-source tool for automatically detecting both nocturnal and diurnal plant–pollinator interactions across natural plant communities and to cross-validate it with direct observations. We foresee that the proposed system has broad applications in research and conservation, providing valuable insights into pollination networks across diverse species and ecosystems., PESM's work was funded by the regional PhD grant FPI-CAIB 009-2022. This study is part of the IslandLife project (Ref. 101054177), funded by an ERC Advanced Grant to AT and is also partially supported by the POLINISLAS project (Ref. 2713/2021). Additional support was provided by the María de Maeztu Excellence Unit (Project CEX2021-001198-M). AL's work was funded by the European Commission—NextGenerationEU, through the Momentum CSIC Programme: Develop Your Digital Talent. AS-R and JB-H acknowledge funding from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (Project PID2021-128966NB-I00), and JB-H also acknowledges support from the Ramón y Cajal Program (Grant RYC2020-030609-I)., Peer reviewed
Proyecto:
EC / HE 101054177
,
AEI / Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación 2021-2023 PID2021-128966NB-I00
,
AEI RYC2020-030609-I
DOI: http://hdl.handle.net/10261/420456, https://api.elsevier.com/content/abstract/scopus_id/105020990903
HANDLE: http://hdl.handle.net/10261/420456, https://api.elsevier.com/content/abstract/scopus_id/105020990903