Pasar al contenido principal

INTUICIONES Y FILOSOFIA EXPERIMENTAL DEL LENGUAJE

PID2023-150396OA-I00

•
Nombre agencia financiadora Agencia Estatal de Investigación
Acrónimo agencia financiadora AEI
Programa Programa Estatal para Impulsar la Investigación Científico-Técnica y su Transferencia
Subprograma Subprograma Estatal de Generación de Conocimiento
Convocatoria Proyectos de I+D+i (Generación de Conocimiento y Retos Investigación)
Año convocatoria 2023
Plan Estatal 2021-2023 Plan Estatal de Investigación Científica y Técnica y de Innovación
Centro beneficiario UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE DE MADRID

Resultados relacionados

Resultados totales (Incluyendo duplicados): 7
Encontrada(s) 1 página(s)

Docta Complutense
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Characterizing asymmetries in the TenTen corpus family membership: an implicit hierarchy in multilingual digital tools

  • Bordonaba Plou, David
  • Jreis Navarro, Laila M
In this work, we examine the limitations of digital tools in facilitating cross-linguistic and cross-cultural research from a humanistic perspective. Our primary objective is to draw comparisons between the TenTen corpora, assessing their degree of similarity. In order to achieve this goal, we will conduct cluster analysis on the 43 corpora within the TenTen Corpus Family using a set of parameters that characterize this family membership. This analysis pinpoints the TenTen corpora that exhibit the most similar characteristics within the family, bringing to the surface an implicit hierarchy within the Sketch Engine platform, a multilingual digital tool environment. This hierarchy is structured into four distinct clusters, definable by size, number of functional tools, versions, and Part-of-Speech (PoS) tagging. The findings of the current study call for prudence when comparing the TenTen corpora, but also suggest a way of improving a multilingual environment; the examination and establishment of connections among the TenTen corpora are imperative for a comprehensive understanding of multilingualism in Digital Humanities.
Docta Complutense
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Is gastronomy a medium for artistic expression? The problem of consumption and the purported asymmetry between aesthetic judgments and judgments of personal preference

  • Bordonaba Plou, David
This paper defends that gastronomy is a medium for artistic expression. It explores two arguments frequently used to defend that gastronomy is not an artistic medium: the problem of consumption and the asymmetry between aesthetic judgments and judgments of personal preference. The former defends that gastronomy and fine arts are fundamentally distinct because their products have very different characteristics. The latter defends that aesthetic judgments and judgments of personal preference differ in that the former are intersubjectively valid, while the latter are only subjectively valid. The paper counters the first argument by suggesting that accepting the problem of consumption leads to an undesirable consequence: the exclusion of certain art forms that are integral to artistic practice. In response to the second argument, the paper contends that empirical evidence from different sources suggests that the asymmetry between aesthetic judgments and judgments of personal preference fails to hold true in numerous contexts.
Minerva. Repositorio Institucional de la Universidad de Santiago de Compostela
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Naturalism: Deep Disagreement or Metalinguistic Negotiation?

  • García Arnaldos, María Dolores
  • Martínez Vidal, Concha
  • Ranalli, Chris
Drawing on the notions of deep disagreement and metalinguistic negotiation, we develop a new interpretation of the debate between scientific naturalism and liberal naturalism over the idea of naturalism. We argue that recent revisions of the debate suggest that the common perception of this as a case of metalinguistic negotiation is misleading. We trace this misperception back to the different ways in which scientific naturalism and liberal naturalism use the term ‘naturalism.’ Once this difference is considered, their seemingly contradictory claims on this issue can apparently be reconciled. It turns out to be a remarkably consequential metalinguistic negotiation over whether the term ‘naturalism’ should be reinterpreted or replaced for the purposes of positive philosophical theorizing. This interpretation explains the genuine disagreement that led scientific naturalism and liberal naturalism to engage in this debate and illuminates the broader meta-philosophical convictions that underlie each of their positions. Finally, we analyze how the development of the principle of charity acts as a mediating argumentative tool in disagreements.
Zaguán. Repositorio Digital de la Universidad de Zaragoza
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Characterizing Asymmetries in the TenTen Corpus Family Membership: An Implicit Hierarchy in Multilingual Digital Tools

  • Bordonaba-Plou, David
  • Jreis-Navarro, Laila M.
In this work, we examine the limitations of digital tools in facilitating cross-linguistic and cross-cultural research from a humanistic perspective. Our primary objective is to draw comparisons between the TenTen corpora, assessing their degree of similarity. In order to achieve this goal, we will conduct cluster analysis on the 43 corpora within the TenTen Corpus Family using a set of parameters that characterize this family membership. This analysis pinpoints the TenTen corpora that exhibit the most similar characteristics within the family, bringing to the surface an implicit hierarchy within the Sketch Engine platform, a multilingual digital tool environment. This hierarchy is structured into four distinct clusters, definable by size, number of functional tools, versions, and Part-of-Speech (PoS) tagging. The findings of the current study call for prudence when comparing the TenTen corpora, but also suggest a way of improving a multilingual environment; the examination and establishment of connections among the TenTen corpora are imperative for a comprehensive understanding of multilingualism in Digital Humanities. Dans ce travail, nous examinons les limites des outils numériques dans la facilitation de la recherche interlinguistique et interculturelle d’un point de vue humaniste. Notre objectif principal est de comparer les corpus TenTen, en évaluant leur degré de similarité. Pour atteindre cet objectif, nous réaliserons une analyse de regroupement sur les 43 corpus de la famille des corpus TenTen en utilisant un ensemble de paramètres caractérisant cette appartenance familiale. Cette analyse identifie les corpus TenTen qui présentent les caractéristiques les plus similaires au sein de la famille, révélant une hiérarchie implicite au sein de la plateforme Sketch Engine, un environnement d’outils numériques multilingues. Cette hiérarchie est structurée en quatre groupes distincts, définis par la taille, le nombre d’outils fonctionnels, les versions et le marquage des parties du discours (PoS). Les résultats de l’étude actuelle appellent à la prudence lors de la comparaison des corpus TenTen, mais suggèrent également un moyen d’améliorer un environnement multilingue ; l’examen et l’établissement de connexions entre les corpus TenTen sont impératifs pour une compréhension complète du multilinguisme dans les Humanités Numériques.
Docta Complutense
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Diferentes nociones de contexto: algunos casos desde la biología sintética, Different notions of context: some cases from synthetic biology

  • Bordonaba Plou, David
  • Céspedes, Esteban
The notion of context has been central to many debates and theories in recent decades. It is well-defined in some disciplines, such as linguistics or philosophy of language. However, there are other disciplines, for example, within the empirical sciences, where this is not always the case. The purpose of this paper is twofold. First, to test whether the different notions of context in the philosophy of language can be applied to the field of synthetic biology in order to gain more clarity in the latter area. In this way, besides contributing to a general characterization of the idea of context that allows a conceptual understanding of contexts, it will also be possible to study their role in scientific and technological research. Second, and to illustrate the fruitfulness of this intersection between disciplines, we show—through the use of corpus methods—how the application of the notion of context from the philosophy of language allows us to shed light on some of the central concepts in synthetic biology, namely, the distinction between synthesis and analysis. On this basis, our perspective will enable us to revisit the relationship between the philosophy of language and the philosophy of biology.
Docta Complutense
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

Are the TenTen corpora really a corpus family? On linguistic tagging and corpora members’ kinship degrees

  • Bordonaba Plou, David
  • Jreis-Navarro, Laila M.
Corpus linguistics is an essential tool in digital humanities, and multilingual corpora are valuable resources in cross-linguistic studies. In this article we address the multilingual layout of the TenTen corpus family, questioning the rationale to call it a family, and advancing the idea of different degrees of kinship for its language members. The analysis focuses on the performance of the Sketch Engine Word Sketch tool in the English Web 2020 corpus (enTenTen20) in comparison with the latest release of the arTenTen, Arabic Web 2018 corpus (arTenTen18), which has been processed by CAMeL tools, an Arabic-specific software, and its previous version, the arTenTen12, tagged with Stanford CoreNLP. The study shows the challenges posed by the platform tools and the tagged corpora regarding the dissimilarities between the available data and the reliability of the results of these tools for both languages, as well as the efforts made to tackle the challenges. The concluding remarks point to the need for a better definition of multilingualism in the TenTen corpora and, by extension, in the digital humanities as a whole, based on the structural design of the resources and tools meant for such theoretical aspirations.
Docta Complutense
Publicación Artículo científico (JournalArticle)

The internal structure of dual character concepts: a corpus-based study of scientist, La estructura interna de los conceptos de doble carácter: un estudio basado en corpus de científico

  • Bordonaba Plou, David
Over the past decade, there has been a growing interest in dual character concepts (DCCs). These concepts are defined by their internal structures, which consist of two distinct dimensions: a descriptive and an independent normative dimension. However, a more in-depth exploration of their internal structures is still needed. This article examines the internal structure of one DCC that has garnered significant attention in the literature, scientist. First, I analyze the components of the different dimensions of this concept. Second, I explore the interaction between these two dimensions. To do so, I investigate scientist in the enTenTen20 corpus using Sketch Engine, focusing on the expressions “good scientist” and “true scientist”, as the literature suggests they interact more directly with the descriptive and normative dimensions, respectively. The findings from this investigation offer valuable insights for studying other DCCs, as the results suggest, among others, the following key points: first, that the complexity of the two dimensions of scientist is greater than previously recognized; and second, contrary to what is agreed, both the descriptive and the normative dimension interact with “good” and “true,” which implies that both expressions can be used to make the two types of normative evaluation proper of DCCs.